Cancer - pointless metaphor n°3
by jjbeguin

Comment:
quality lighting, detail, color, composition. 9

Ripples in Aries
by mrblobby

Comment:
nicely caught ripples. The symbol is pretty sharp too. The ripples are so subtle compared to the hard, shiny metal, that some of the impact is lost. Perhaps b&w or monottone would balance this out?

The Water Pourer
by Coley

Comment:
The jug has a wonderful glowing quality to it. The lightiing is really fantastic. You caught the water well. I'd crop in more - lose some of the blackness. 9

Libra: Can you make up your mind?
by valborg

Comment:
Nice golden light. I like that you chose another angle than straight on. I wish there were better focus. Even if just the front part were sharp and the rest blurry, that would go well with the title, even the focus would be weighing the options.

THE ORIGINAL CAPRICORN
by RUEDISCHMUTZ

Comment:
Awsome horns. NIce details and color on the goat. I wish the background was even more out of focus, so the goat would stand out even more.

Aries - Friendship and Loyalty
by kuark

Comment:
Nice idea. You've got some great detail with the lines in the hand, and I likr the sepia tone. 3 fingertips are over-bright. 8

Setting A Heart On Fire
by nds

Comment:
wonderful use of light. I am interested to see your comments after the challenge and learn exactly how you did this. Compelling composition, lovely background. 9

The Water Bearer
by Catherine

Comment:
The color fo the water and the hand and the quality of the light are wonderful. That shadow is distracting though. Maybe a bit less white on the left, 7

Libra
by RichT8496

Comment:
interesting to have the subject be what you can barely see - the balance. But the weights and the shadows they cast. Very cool looking image. I wish the shadows were more distinct, they have a lot of space to fill for being fuzzy. But then again isn;t that the problem with Libras (I am one) we weigh things, but can never quite make up our minds, they are always fuzzy. 8

Pisces are always in pairs... no matter what colour.
by JoelHSmith

Comment:
nice colors, fine reflections. I'd crop the black on the top - the fishies are swallowed up by all that space above them. Cropping down draws the eyes in more and them the eye can follow your wonderful line of fish.