right side up...and down (maybe)
by jsc9306

Comment:
The photo seems flat and not that interesting. Grayscaling it might have made it score better with me. Or even adding food coloring to the water to give it more 'punch'. 4 from me. Keep it up though, I don't think I could've done better if I had entered this challenge.

Below a web of light
by jprezant

Comment:
Beautiful shot, great symmetry and another one where B&W do justice. Because it's a nice shot, it's hard to give any useful comments. I will be picky and say that some of the lights look a bit blown, but I don't know that you could control that. Also, the windown on the left side seems to be darker near the bottom and throughout really. 9 from me.

UIUIU
by tate

Comment:
Great shot, great idea. Being picky, it's too bad you couldn't do something about the background. 8 from me.

Forks
by lear202bt

Comment:
Nice idea. Love the B&W. I can't really give much advice on a good photo like so I'm just going to say job well done. 7 from me.

Star Fruit
by stargazer05766

Comment:
Is it me, or is there a lot of noise in this picture. It is a nice picture but I would be careful of noise. That, or the star fruit is super small and we're getting in close to your skin and that's just the texture of the skin. 6 from me.

Waiting, En Masse
by chan

Comment:
I wasn't sure what I was looking at. Had to get my wife here to point out that they are chairs (They are chairs right?). Definitely meets the challenge, but it's kind of boring. Nice try though! 5 from me.

Wakehurst Place
by marbo

Comment:
IR filter? I love IR and can't wait to do it myself. I think you lost some detail in the building. Hindesite is 2020 but I would've put something in the middle of the path like a yellow rubber duck, and cut the house out of it completely. The path itself is very nice, but would've made a boring shot on it's own. However, had you put something (Anything really) in the middle of the path, you would have score much better I think. I do realize that that is not the shot you were going for here, but perhaps for another challenge you could. 7 from me.

Stigma
by mfiman

Comment:
That center piece feels like it's popping out of the screen at me. Almost 3D like. Nice image.

Shape
by TimmyQ

Comment:
Great idea. Simple too (Although I think it might have taken time to actually setup the shot). I like the idea and there's not much I can say that would help. If I were to be super picky I would say that on the left of the bottle there seems to be a smudge of some kind on the background. Not sure what that is. 9 from me.

Tower Of Power
by liberty

Comment:
I'm not sure what you did to the image but it looks very blocky with the white. Did you maybe over-sharpen the image? If you could've gotten a clearer shot of the tower, while keep that sky the way it is, you would have scored much better IMO. 3 from me.