Giving thanks for the food we eat
by WILDBLUE

Comment:
The plate is dirty which ruins this image. Spot editing isn;t allowed, but cleaning it before hand would have been a better option.

The fork is also pixelated.

Meal looks tasty! and interesting composition. Well exoposed with balck & white being so dominating.

One Healthy But SILLY Kid
by OneSweetSin

Comment:
Out of focus and an awful frame. Good pose on the kid though.

My son James
by Neuferland

Comment:
A snap-shot? Slightly OOF and a messy image overall.

Woudl eb nice as a record keeping shot, but not so good in a challenge I feel.

For good eyesight
by train

Comment:
Dark areas either side are distracting. Also eyes shoudl be looking into the camera for optimum effect....

To the Lord & for those who have/do fought for our Freedoms.
by vtruan

Comment:
Sorry, but this will get panned I think. All you have done is take a picture of someone elses work.

The title is also bad "do fought " doesn't make sense.

The composition leaves a lot to be desired too, why include the pole on the right? I see you tried to get the flag in which is very nice, but the top pole is very distracting and ruins the image.

On the plus side, the color is quite nice if a little over staurated. Nice as a photo, but not in a challenge.

Thanks God for Him
by cimarron98

Comment:
bad points the grey area at the top left. the ditracting background buildings.
Good points great superb perfect contrast. i hate those wishy-washy white images that 99% of people do. This is just my taste. Nice and sharp also.
Overall Score 5

Give thanks to mother nature
by robsmith

Comment:
bad points main subject is OOF if that is the leaf? Quite a lot going on that si quite dull.
Good points like the long format, but think it's wasted as there is nothing going on up top.
Overall Score 3

Logan
by dsidwell

Comment:
bad points Not enough contrast on the face, composed too much to the left.
Good points nice to see someone actualy taking an image with eye contact! Super detail in the hair - great texture.
Overall Score 4

The Gift of Life!
by Artifacts

Comment:
bad points the fuzzy mess at the top, what is it?
Good points fairly iconic representation.
Overall Score 2

Four Hearts
by Coley

Comment:
bad points very underexposed. Unless you all have grey hands ;) Composition could have been improved if the circle formed by the hands was central
Good points nice choice of black BG
Overall Score 2