sad bananas
by rend

Comment:
i must admit at first glance i did not like this shot...but it grows on me, and i have already seen at least 15 shots that do not convey an emotion at all. i am givin this a 10 for being both well shot and out of the box as we like to say

Can't stop reading!!!
by Kismet

Comment:
sorry, i dont feel "reading" is an emotion...maybe the excitement of it...

Pure Concentration
by Brookied

Comment:
sorry this is a nice shot but i dont consider concentration an emotion /5

Captain Morgan & Coke...the Ultimate Relaxer
by Hipychik

Comment:
oh man you are speaking my language with capt and coke but i do not find define relaxed as either extreme or emotion /4

oh baby
by leko2k

Comment:
sexy and tasteful 8

Tom
by holdingtime

Comment:
i see a nice shot but i do not see an extreme emotion...many people feel that a good shot should be judged in and of itself, i do not agree, there is no need to have challenge guidelines if they are not followed, if this were a candid,b&w or bokeh challenge i would give this a 10 as it is, i feel i must give no higher than a 6. and as always this is JMO

The First Anniversary
by bassbone

Comment:
i like the concept tho i find the b&w to be a tad bit flat /7

definition of portrait - likeness of person or animal (this is an animal!)
by roz

Comment:
ahh roz my sweet friend, looks like you split the masses on this one...mine finished quite low and critisized as well....BUT I BEAT YOU BUWAHAHAHAHAHA!!!!!!!

:)

edit to add that i also agree that the 80 votes of 4 or less is pretty ridiculous...

J

Message edited by author 2007-07-25 01:59:30.

lines
by rodgers_le

Comment:

Originally posted by ragamuffingirl: Like how the only thing really in focus is her tits! Actually if it wasn't for your crappy DOF, I would have voted this quite high. But, it's clear what you consider the important part of this person to be.

is it not possible to offer criticism without being so damned rude?

storm of uncertainty
by smurfguy

Comment:
in all challenges there are the shots you feel got robbed, this is one for me, lovely...