Long Forgotten
by LoudDog

Comment:
Beautiful shot! I love this type of work. A very nit pick suggestion would be to give it a mild mid-tone compression to bring out the detail in the darker areas. Nice shot.

Memories of Lynchburg
by L1

Comment:
Beautiful composition, But I'm afraid it will get hit hard for being a duotone. Great detail and wood grain.

Melodic Memories
by smithma

Comment:
Great composition! It looks just slightly flat, but that just adds to the old dusty feel of it. very nice work and creative use of depth.

November
by Koriyama

Comment:
This is one of my top 2 in this challenge! This is just beautiful. Perfect exposure!

November
by Jacko

Comment:
WOW! My first 10.... This is beautiful!
The color looks natural and not over saturated. Great depth of field from the foreground leaves back to the last trees. Very nice color combo with the rich green against the red leaves.

Ragin' Cajun
by sher

Comment:
The position of the white hat against the dark background along with the white shirt, completely balances the shot in the frame. I have shot enough concerts and festivals to know how difficult it is to capture a shot this clean and crisp. The clarity is impressive. I do like the unusual colorcast, it's a bit on the green side on my monitors. I can't help but wonder how many will see this as brown, red or yellow due to monitor calibration. (Just a ramble of thought).
Good positioning,
Great clarity,
Interesting subject,
This is one of my top picks for the challenge.
.... Good luck, it looks great.

Eve
by Zoomdak

Comment:
This is just beautiful! 10
A little mid-tone compression might bring out more depth to the clouds and more definition to the canyon. The colors are very real and not over done. This is one of my favorite in the challenge.

The Great Smoky Mountains
by DougPaz

Comment:
Just simply spectacular! 10
The clear rich colored hill in the foreground is so perfectly placed. It brings an element of distance into the shot. I think by giving this a little mid tone compression you can bring out a little more of the detail on the ridges. This is just an incredible view and an excellent photograph!

Lighthouse
by Keith Maniac

Comment:
Aaah, The Portland Lighthouse in Chicago. I love the panoramic crop on this. The placement is good. The sky has just a little more grain in it than I like in my sky and the color could use just a slight boost i think to give the sky and the red roof a little more punch. (that's a personal preference thing). Over-all, a great shot...
Good luck 7

Spirit of a Tree
by digistoune

Comment:
This is just a fantastic picture in every way! Black/White is a great choice here. The shadow, highlights and detail all superb. 10