The Cut -- Where the Rain Never Ends
by karmat

Comment:
Very nice black and white photo. I know it is a difficult shot with fog and rain. Just a little sharper for my tastes. Still a 7 to me

Happy
by mariomel

Comment:
A 1-3?! Give me a break!! In the way I judge...everything is a 5...average. This has great focus, depth and color. Skin tones look good with the red tube coloring it. I would have given it a 6-7. I am still trying to figure out peoples method of judging a photo.
Tracy
//photos4aidan.home.attbi.com

Next stop: The Gulf.
by SharQ

Comment:
In my opinion...a vertical shot would have captured the whole subject, but that is my preference.

Thorns of Despair
by gerard

Comment:
With the aperture open just a bit more, the focus on the whole thing would be much better.

Glasses and card
by Gren

Comment:
Just a bit too fuzzy, but I get the idea...without your glasses this is the way it would look.

Moment of Weakness
by Clou9

Comment:
A little out of focus and the flash tends to overpower the front half of the photo, but still a great idea

Bloodcup: Drink of Strength and Spirt
by Anachronite

Comment:
After reading all the comments, it comes to me that there are many different types of people here. One thing I am seeing is, alot of people go on the merit of the photo (technical, etc.), while others only go on a moral issue. I agree with it being a little dark, but it being in the superstitions challenge...PERFECT, because that is what it is. To me, if it causes a little emotion, along with being a good photo...I like it even more! I'd given ya a seven!!
Tracy
photos4aidan.home.attbi.com

Oh Despair what am I to do
by Ryboflavin

Comment:
way out of focus. what is it?

Young Despair
by matt

Comment:
I can't see the picture ):

Poor TY
by nitro102

Comment:
little out of focus, but pulls at the heart strings