Dishing
by xianart

Comment:
Very well done!

Dirt Bag
by karmat

Comment:
I think I am going to puke.... 7 for the photography and the concept, but I am taking one away for making me feel ill!

Today's Special - Dirt Pie w/ a Side of Worms
by aimeethetoo

Comment:
LOL - and nicely done, too.

Dirt- Nothing More....Nothing Less
by Spizzer

Comment:
Hmmm, I have a problem in voting for this one, as I haven't got a clue what I am looking at, nor how it meets the challenge.

Dirt on White
by fotomann_forever

Comment:
I find this a bit stark and dull.

What lies beneath
by BrennanOB

Comment:
Compositionally an uncomfortable shot to view - it seems that this is just a quick snapshot, with no prior conception of what the end photograph would look like.

Make Mine, Dirt A Touch of Fertilizer & Water……Please
by BrianR

Comment:
Focus, exposure etc are fine, but the composition doesn't work for me.

Red Fields of Sugarcane
by sherpet

Comment:
I am not particularly keen on your post-processing. The canes actually change colour as they hit the horizon, and the horizon itself seems tobe showing signs of chromatic abberation. I suspect that you have boosted the contrast level a great deal - personally I would have prferred a more subtle approach.

Uncle Sam's Prescribed Relief!
by littlegett

Comment:
I was so suprised to see that this photo wasn't in the top ten - never mind so far down the rankings. I was very impressed by it - the texture, graininess and darkness add to the overall sense of sadness, desperation,seediness. I find it powerful, and it certainly had the most profound effect on me of any photo in the challenge.

In silent company with solitude,forever!
by chugginrail

Comment:
I was sorry to see this hadn't done better with the voters. For me it really did provide an illustration of an idea of the moment of death, and I gave it one of my higher marks.