Storm
by jduffett

Comment:
Here in York we have had the grand total of half an inch of snow this winter. Not fair ;¬P

Dream ride
by Valdo

Comment:
I feel that this would have benefitted from a shallower depth of field (hard at night, I know - and I am not sure whether I could have done it) in order to let the horse and carriage stand out, as the background is very busy. On first pass I failed to notice the resting driver who, at the end of the day, is the 'subject'! I would like to see the photo more titly framed, perhaps cropped so that just half the carriage and half the horse are included.

What are you looking at?!
by sickdog

Comment:
The composition here is alittle tight for my taste, and the photo has a rather washed out appearance. There is something about the texture (or perhaps lack of) of the dog's coat and the boy's hand that bothers me.

Street Corner
by FocusPoint

Comment:
Not keen on the partial desaturation, although it does appear well done.

Street Market
by brettt83

Comment:
Whilst this is a photo of a street scene, it doesn't draw me in and ask questions about the lives of those depicted. The scene is very busy, and it is hard to make out details - I feel that it would have been more beneficial to centre in on just one of the groups of people.

My Wife Hates the Smell
by timfythetoo

Comment:
I'm not in the least bit suprised - foul habit! Good low-key portrait - practicing for this weeks challenge?

Music Teacher: A Kids Perspective - "I ...said...On...FOOOUUUURRRR!!!"
by cogerox

Comment:
Sorry about the DQ - had this still been in the challenge when I voted, I would have give it an 8. The idea and composition is superb. The only thing that lets it down (and only a little) for me is the slightly soft focus and perhaps the lighting. Would be interested to see a re processed version with some burning etc.

IMG_3080--1_filtered-640427.jpg
by nards656

Comment:
I spotted this in the 'recently uploaded' section, but didn't note whose it was - I am really glad to re-find it. This sort of scene is really tricky to compose and expose well, but you have succeeded on both counts - nice one!

Comfort
by hanneke

Comment:
This is beautiful, so tender.

Punctuality
by NerdJNerdBird

Comment:
The only ten I gave out in this challenge was to this photo - I really did expect to see it the top ten at the very least. To me it nailed the challenge and the technicals are all good, especially the outstanding composition. Most importantly, 'though, it tells a story and provides the viewer with a feast of visual stimulus, but without over-bombarding the senses. Reviewing the photo again after close of voting, I stand by my vote of 10. Good one!