Hiding in a Silhouette
by illusionary

Comment:
To work well silhouettes need to clearly define a shape. Here the picture is too cluttered; for example, the two buildings to the left of the subject are distracting and cause the silhouette of your model to become less ditinct.

Glam under the pier
by jblaylockrayner

Comment:
I feel this would have made a far more interesting photo without the model.

BEAUTY
by ericwoo

Comment:
That looks just plain silly!

Skillz
by scalvert

Comment:
The differences between this and your actual Free Study entry may only be subtle, but I much prefer this one. I note that you prefer the boy's expression on the other one, but I think this one works much better - it has attitude!

Big Air, Strong Legs
by option

Comment:
O-M-G....

Krystal
by blissmoi

Comment:
As with Jeff, I still can't work out how this fits in with the challenge. On a more important note, the photo should actually be disqualified because it was not taken within the week following the challenge anouncement. The challenges are just that, a challenge to the members to produce a photo that meets a specific criteria in a short and defined space of time.

Unfair Advantage
by gloda

Comment:
My only 10; absolutely outstanding.

Driving Force
by jmsetzler

Comment:
I expected this to score much higher(I gave a 7) - I like the composition, and am impressed with your tonal range; I suspect it may work better as a print.

Untitled
by Gnarf

Comment:
I gave this a 9; it was certainly in my top 10! I thought the composition masterly - a very understated photograph, that for me works extremely well.

Morning Tranquility
by glad2badad

Comment:
Astounded that this didn't rank higher - I think it a gorgeous photo; so serene and under-stated.