Day 11: Cookies!
by levyj413

Comment:
Hee hee, box up some of those Samoas and send them down to Charleston, please. On the other hand, don't. Last time I got some my husband wolfed down the entire box - okay, actually three boxes - in one day.

Day 13: House
by levyj413

Comment:
Isn't it amazing what PP can do? This looks just like a painting. Not to knock your photo, of course. Without a decent composition and exposure it would be a very bad painting, and instead it is very appealing, with a cozy winter look.

7 Years of Bad Luck
by Photologist

Comment:
Interesting idea and very nice composition. The title really suits the photo and contest as well. It's pretty cool how the pieces of mirror made such an intriguing pattern, which you captured well. If there is anything I'd consider changing, it would be a little less saturation. Great photo!

Road? What road?
by Kivet

Comment:
Underrated IMO. I really like the subtle shapes and grays. Sorry I didn't vote in this challenge, because I would have given you at least a 7. A little more negative space on the left wouldn't hurt, but then again, nearly the whole photo is negative space. Which I like. Great job.

Bad Conditions
by bryantbus

Comment:
This has got to be the most foul toilet in all of Buffalo. Maybe even the entire state of NY, and I imagine you've got some pretty stiff competition on that one :-) I do like the comment from Santiago, below.
Definitely not a bad photo (pun intended) of what it is. I don't get the feeling you were going for something to hang in a museum, though. 'Course maybe MOMA will accept it.

The Abomination
by Blue Moon

Comment:
Leah,
I must be colorblind, because I actually really like the scheme you have going on here. It's one of those photos that is so over the top it works :-) I didn't vote in this challenge, but I would have been one of your higher scores if I had. The whole pink&green thing is pretty common down here in SC, where it has a connotation of preppiness. No joke. You'll have to try harder if you want to really submit something bad :-)

morning lite on Bells
by griz210

Comment:
Hi David,
I've noticed this photo before when browsing through portfolios, and was very surprised it hadn't scored higher. The light and green tones on the trees are stunning.

conservatory.jpg
by mngolfer

Comment:
I agree that this is an interesting shot, and glad that Kelli pointed it out! Love the perspective and lines here.

Sliding
by xianart

Comment:
I really like the simplicity and composition in this photo. I gave it a better than average vote in a difficult challenge for those reasons. I also find the lighting lovely. The only detracting aspect to me is the shadow extending back from the sled, which leads my eye out of the photo.

good as gold
by skewsme

Comment:
I think this is really underrated. I gave it a much higher score. I love the colors and simplicity of the lines. It has a look of a cat praying, which could be interpreted in a multitude of ways. I also really like how the whiskers disappear into the white, then reappear on the shutter. Excellent shot IMO - don't let the score get you down!