Fall color 1
by Melethia

Comment:
love blurry feet

Fall color 2
by Melethia

Comment:
nice to see you still have fall colours! We have a blanket of the white stuff. I like this very much. Nice to see blue sky, even if it's only in a picture.

Absorbed
by snaffles

Comment:
Greetings from the Critique Club

It's been a while Susan, since I've done a critique :)

Well done on the top 30 placing with this image.

I assume you were using a tripod also to get the nice blur of the water.

As far as composition is concerned, I think placing the subject in the centre of the frame has cost you a few points. I have a feeling that if you had chosen to use a horizontal orientation and included a little bit more of the river to the right of the frame you may have had a more dynamic photo which could well have pushed you over the 6.

Overall I think this is rather nicely done. Good job!

07340001cdp.jpg
by Iraklis

Comment:
Now this is really cool. I haven't started using my Holga yet, but seeing this I am really intrigued to see what they come out like.

Polaroid SX-70_01
by krnodil

Comment:
I definitely like the polaroid look.

Thank You
by paynekj

Comment:
This could be an image taken in the 70s. You don't often see charity boxes like that anymore.

Accidental self portrait
by TrollMan

Comment:
Ha, look at all the fly by voters who clearly didn't even look at the image properly. So far from being DNMC. What a very well done image and seriously should have scored a lot higher. Had I voted it would definitely have been a high score from me.

Walking Upstream
by Paul

Comment:
One of my faves in this challenge.

femme
by rinac

Comment:
Rina, should have been the blue in my opinion, but well done on ribboning anyway. This is a simply stunning image.

femme
by rinac

Comment:
This is such a wonderful image. I can't imagine it not being on the front page.