House of Sand and Fog
by noraneko

Comment:
I really like the repeating patterns here. You have a good eye for composition. You know me though, I am a stickler for people. Put a person (or a bird in your case) in that bottom left third and bam one in a million. :)

But as a pure landscape, I think it is wonderful. Capturing fog is always difficult and easily accomplished the mood. Stunning photo.

Message edited by author 2007-05-03 21:11:58.

Kite
by JuliBoc

Comment:
Zero comments, that's a shame.

Voters are fickle... sometimes they like negative space sometimes they don't. Tough scene to capture since the action is so small, however I like the intent... stark red against the blue sky.

One mantra my professor always stated, "Fill the Frame". I think if you would have cut this into a portrait orientation you would have had a much stronger photo. Though, take my ramblings lightly, my average is lower than yours. :)

As far as pure technicals, the image is nearly perfect.

NINA_IMG_1846.jpg
by dsterner

Comment:
Wonderful facial expression. The number one key in taking a good portrait. Lighting is a bit harsh. If going for strictly for a portrait, try positioning yourself in the shade with the sun behind you shining on Nina's face. If a candid then no worries. Still terrific expression and a great portrait to look at.

BW-pinebough.jpg
by JerseyGenie

Comment:
This would have worked really well in symmetry in my opinion. Good use of depth of field and good use of the frame. Good stuff.

Message edited by author 2007-05-03 20:58:31.

Day 2 - Castle Hill Lighthouse
by CapeSail

Comment:
I saw the difference between this and the edited version. I actually prefer this version as it seems more "real" especially in the clouds. Wonderful shot. Good lines and overall composition.

Day-3
by SandyP

Comment:
Wonderful shot SandyP. A good choice for B&W. Great composition.

Taking Center Stage
by SandyP

Comment:
I don't think I gave you a big congrats. What a stunning image. Terrific detail in the butterfly.

When is a fried egg not a fried egg?
by snaffles

Comment:
I like this, it feels like a study of circles/soft lines. Everything is very smooth which really adds to the composition. I think you are pushing it with the 1/8s second as I can see a bit of motion blur and perhaps a slight WB tweak. :) Still I thought the content was terrific and I actually scored you pretty during the challenge. Those soft lines!

simple
by krnodil

Comment:
Congrats on the well deserved score and placement. A very POW factor shot, almost reminds me of modern product commercials (ie. razors). Very cool overall, might try to isolate the light in the grater a bit if you ever take a retake, still a very nicely seen and executed shot.

Day-2
by SandyP

Comment:
Great shot and terrific lighting. I really like the graceful line in this picture ending in the waterfall.