Birds
by 4trtone

Comment:
Hmmm? Not sure if the rule works here. The dead-space seems to be where a subject should be? The focus and colors are nice...and since your photo is very similar to mine (don't tell anybody!)...I'll bump it up just bit more. 7

Everything and the Moon
by LucidLotus

Comment:
Wow...if everything besides the Moon is a rose, I'd have to say you're very easy to please! };>) I'm having trouble with the thirds...the whole thing seems kinda top-heavy to me...I'm not being very helpful in this challenge.

Sun Worshipers
by lil_mo

Comment:
For me, the placement of the second largest flower is perfect. It's the closest one that is bothering me for some reason...sorry...I'm not much help.

Wild Berries
by BeckyT

Comment:
The colors and focus are excellent...I just think the berries, I'm guessing they are the subject...are too low in the frame.

Waiting for Prey
by rmtm333

Comment:
Meow...I think it would have meow done very good meow...except I think there is a meow strange reflection going on...meow. Sorry, it just made me think of something a long time ago when I was a kid. Something from Mr. Rogers neighborhood...sorry...meow!

Chemistry...
by bvlro

Comment:
It's not really working for me...the third part...I don't think the subjects should touch the border. Maybe I'm wrong.

Plowing the Fallow Ground
by Buckeye_Fan

Comment:
I'm wondering why you placed the subject in the lower left? Is that really fallow ground? Anyway...it's a very nice photo...8

Rocky Mountian Goat
by trailwalker

Comment:
I kinda hate judging these...it just seems the goat is a little high (in the frame...doh!) and maybe it's just me, but the trees seem in better focus then the body of the goat. Still...don't let those things get yours...I like the photo...8

The lady in the water
by LalliSig

Comment:
You know, I'm kinda new to photography...this rule of thirds thing...to me, it seems like the subject is not quite what I understand the rule to be...but...with the reflection...it brings the subject to center of a third. I'm not sure if that's what the challenge was. But, it's a great photo - focus, color and lighting. I'm sure you'll get bonus points for the model (!). I'll give it an 8 because I think could be tilted to the right ever so slightly.

Deploy the skimmer..to the starboard third!
by dustinwilson

Comment:
S.O.S. - I'm all wet...it took me a second to see all the thrids...great! My brother is in the Coast Guard. I'll give it a 10.