Weathered
by SDW

Comment:
Looks a little blurred at the base, but I hope you find time/inclination to process this black and white - I think it would look great. Looks good as is, but BW would really show off the grunge on that statue. Nice one.

Shadows
by SDW

Comment:
Of all your recent batch of shots, I like this one best. In part because I like architecture shots, and in part because of the stark contrast between the red and black. I would rotate it clockwise a hair to try and get things level, but really this is great. I love the shadows too. That little light and the windows on the one door break up the picture just enough to keep it from looking sterile. This is a really nice photo.

Silent Whisper
by rubienne

Comment:
Interesting colors and subject. DOF wrecks this photo though. 3.

Zen & the Art of Architecture
by lwkimages

Comment:
It's a nice shot, like the color and the composition. It gives me a sense of nightmare though as it is so unnatural. To that end, I don't find serenity or harmony here. Ethereal - yes, other worldly - yes, gothic - yes. Nice shot, just not the shot for this challenge. 5.

Chopsticks
by shudderbug

Comment:
Very simplistic. Certainly presents a serene image. The composition would benefit from moving the plants down and more to the right and cropping out about half of them. Overall this needs more contrast. Meets the challenge, but the shot itself could use some work. 5.

Midnight Sun
by andy74

Comment:
Nice photo, I'm sure it will fare well. The pier (I assume it's a pier) is a big distraction here. An odd angle on it, completely blacked out anyways. It interupts the eye when taking in an otherwise perfect attempt at capturing the mood of the challenge (serene, harmony, etc). Like the colors, like how the blades of grass break up the water. Very nice. 5.

the heart of the matter
by IreneM

Comment:
This is an interesting image. I like the material you've used and the textures it presents. I like how the lighting plays across it. The yellow/greenish banding in certain areas detracts greatly (and I've checked this on 3 monitors now). Possibly a shallower DOF would enhance the shot. Composition is nice. This has a very edgy feel to me though, something that might have been muted with a little blur or more subdued lighting especially in that center hotspot. It doesn't show me harmony or serenity and even though it is a simple object it is a very complex arrangement of lines for the eyes to follow. So I'm judging it a good photo that wasn't so hot for this challenge. 5.

Silent Sentinels
by Melethia

Comment:
I like the dreamy effect here. Very serene, good balance between sky and earth. Meets the challenge well. Trees should be in sharp focus, doing so would not destroy the effect. I would also move them to the right and crop out that little scraggly one. Horizon is a bit sloped. Overall, a nice shot. 5.

B R E A T H E
by -Bec-

Comment:
Composition is good. Nice color on the background void. Overall, it just doesn't grab me. I'm sorry I can't give some technical insight as to why, but it just doesn't do it for me. Possibly some better lighting on the cloth that would give some better contrast and bring out those wrinkles and folds. Not sure.

Zen Photography
by MayaM

Comment:
Very, very busy photo. Looks to be a bit oversharpened and there is simply too much for they eye to focus on. Shallower DOF maybe, cutting off right behind that little ornament. Overall it's just too busy (and a bit too dark) to promote the sense of serentiy, balance and harmony that is the goal of the challenge. 4.