Pale Ale
by Kelli

Comment:
I gave this a 5. If it were just a perfectly exposed, sharp photo of a glass of ale I would have given it a 4, but I gave you an extra point for the daring processing. You pushed it to the very edge of visibility, so that even though the rim and base are visible on your monitor, they are pretty much invisible on some of the voters' monitors, including mine. And that explains the low score. The things I vote up for, other people vote down for.

p.s. the reason I was voting this low in the first place is because I don't like studio/product shots and I feel a photo should have a reason to exist other than fulfilling the challenge.

The Sentinel
by Brad

Comment:
A little too much blank space, I think. Have you tried a square crop? Still, this is one of the best shots I've seen so far.

In a Doll's Dream
by briantammy

Comment:
Remarkable. It's as if the doll were made just to sniff that bottle. 9

A light meal
by beaflies

Comment:
Good use of feather! It really pops right out of the photo. 9

CAT
by rtscribbs02

Comment:
This is so funny and weird and heartrending. Don't ask me why. 9

still life with bananas and a green vase
by agenkin

Comment:
painterly. 8

Split Personality
by Giorgio

Comment:
I'm not crazy about all the empty space, but I love the pose and you gotta love forks. 8

Never too tired to be seated.
by Patmania

Comment:
Creepy. Otherworldly. 9

Nature's cupcakes
by hanneke

Comment:
This doesn't look like a single photograph, much like a Hendrix guitar solo doesn't sound like a single guitar. 9

Winter is here
by garlic

Comment:
Fantastic eye. I've been in woods like that and haven't been able to find a shot. 10.