Then bring friends around it.
by jjbeguin

Comment:
Wish I knew what all kinds of cheese these were. Hope I can explain this so you can understand. It's a little "dull", making it appear dark when it is not dark. The colors are all dead or dull colors starting with the table. To have gotten all of the wine bottle, the only thing with any life in the color, in you would have added more dead empty space in the top right corner. It's not that it's a bad photo, it's just not a really good photo, in spite of the good technical qualities you have. I hope this makes sense. But of course this is just my opinion of it. I'd have to give it a 4 personally.

Alright, Who's Got the Hot Milk?!!
by Antithesis

Comment:
Looks like a baptism we did in Khazaksthan in 50 degree temperature. This must be something simular to be dressed this way on an obviously cold day. Great photo of the people. Love the colors, the focus, the cropping the composition, but wouldn't know it was about milk without the title. I believe to fit the challenge it must show the challenge without the title. The best I could give it would be a 4.

Don't Rub me the Wrong Way
by Konador

Comment:
What does this have to do with "Got Milk" except maybe for grating cheese. If that's it, it needs some cheese. To me it's too much of a stretch to say it met the challenge. But it is a really clear and sharp close-up of a grater. All I would be able to give it for the challenge is a 4 though.

Contradiction
by mliborio

Comment:
Good idea just needs better execution. Would have come across better if you couldn't see the seem between the table and wall. As is, you can see that the camera was tilted, not the glass. Good attempt. Everything in focus with nice cropping. Like the "coke' glass idea. Still worth a 7 for the photograph quality.

Wanna Cookie?
by karmat

Comment:
What's the blue on the glass by the cookie? First thing I saw. Good choice of background. Looks like taken with camera at an angle, good job. Great focus and cropping. I like the frame and think it adds to this photo, usually don't. Great job. Would be worth an 8.

A Politically Incorrect Drinking Establishment?
by ChrisW123

Comment:
This is fantastic. You'd have to be from the south to get the full impact. Can't believe you found this. Photo is beautiful also. Nice and clear focus, good lighting, nice composition. I love it. It's worth a 10 to a southern.

Seventeen
by emorgan49

Comment:
This tugs at the ole heart strings. We see too many of these road signs anymore. I'd like to see more make it to 10. This is a great photo all the way around. I'll give it a 9.

Onward
by Alec

Comment:
Awesome photo. This should make the top 10. The fog makes it along with the sepia tone. Great job. I love it. You get my first 10

Ironic
by teachme53

Comment:
Need just a tad bit more focus. But good shot. Worth a 6.

Low Flight at Night
by av8orboy

Comment:
Had to really strain but could read the "Low Flying Aircraft" sign. Nice one. Have to sit there long to catch this? My only complaint is I wish the sign showed up better and were easier to read. But I'll still give it a 7.