oh no, not another centrally-placed-flower-picture!
by Camabs

Comment:
Whilst one rose is in the centre the others are not, therefore not fitting the subject IMO None of the flowers are in focus, yes the centre one a bit more but really not enough to draw my eye to it as the subject matter. The white in the back is also very distracting. Work on your composition and removing distracting elements from your images.

25 16 5: An Abstraction in Cheap Jars
by davidw

Comment:
Everyone's interpretation of a 'centered composition' will vary. For me this image doesn't work for the subject. Yes, it sort of is centered but then again it's not. Maybe is you had given it more of a wide angle view with more room around the items to really put them in a centered position it would have worked better. The glasses are also not very interesting. They don't draw me in and make me want to look at at the image for any length of time.

General Grievous - Star Wars III
by HarveyG

Comment:
This is a nice macro shot. Good bokeh but the subject on this occasion is not very interesting.

Soir d'automne
by keyz

Comment:
This is an interesting image but viewing it in the context of being a centered composition, I find that the part that draws my eyes is the lighting in the leaves and this is making it more of a split composition. The darkness has not worked for this subject IMO.

looking at a parkbench
by cutout

Comment:
Great image. Will be interesting to see how this was done in basic editing.

Play
by spiritualspatula

Comment:
Congratulations on your first ribbon. Love this shot.

firey end to summer
by chrisp

Comment:
I don't find that this image meets the challenge. Comes across as a landscape with the sun setting, not an image whos subject is foliage.

Night Fall
by asij

Comment:
The subject it Foliage, so probably the wrong challenge to shoe-horn this into. Nice image but scored low.

Best Friends
by timfythetoo

Comment:
Nice one Tim. Don't forget to do the screen shot ;)

When the Spell backfires...
by Lydia

Comment:
I didn't vote in this challenge but this would have been my top pic so I'm glad it got the blue ribbon. Fabulous shot. Congratulations.