medpc.jpg
by deapee

Comment:
Wonderful lighting to enchance the expression!

Prankster causes outrage from gas station patrons
by Elvis_L

Comment:
Wow that would be terrible. Great addition into the challenge.

The Man In The Window
by TUBORG

Comment:
*Critique Club*

"The Man In The Window" was a prefect addition into the Window Framed challenge. The strong colors just grab my attention right of the bat.

The image is something you can easily become engrossed in. The window frame itself is pretty interesting, especially with the deep blue sky. But the include of your friend, Wow, great thinking! I love the outfit. The depth of the shot is really great, it doesn't feel flat. The layers between the frame, its edges, the blue sky and your friend really enhance the work. Your composition and lighting are excellent. You have taken a great completely shot, nothing is missing. I wish I had more to say but this is just an excellent photo and I have to say congratulations.

In from the rain.
by mysticred

Comment:
*Critique Club*

"In from the rain." is a nice addition into the Window Framed challenge. I personally really liked the perspective of this shot.

Overall this is a striking image because of the warm colors you choose. I think the warmth comes from the coloring of the wood. The gentleman's expression is very interesting. I also thought like some voters that you were going for more of a historical piece probably from the red, white and blue in contrast to his outfit. I think the focus could have been a touch sharper , especially on his face. But working through a pane of glass (I assume) could make the focus really challenging. Overall this is a nice shot. Personally I thought it would place higher, but I am a huge fan of warm, rich images.

Good work and I am glad to see a new personal best for you! Keep up the good work.

Who came home to see me?
by meyers

Comment:
"Who came home to see me?" is a cute addition into the Window Framed challenge.

The image itself grabs attention because it is such a cute little boy looking at us (the voters). You have meet the challenge by framing our subject. I personally had a hard time with the challenge because none of my windows came out as clear as I wanted, so I choose not to enter. I had a hard time voting on shot like yours because I know how hard it was to try and get the shot, but the glare/haze takes away from the shot. I think the shot would have scored higher if the glass had been clear to the viewers. I am not sure how much straightening the frame would help out the score. I think I probably would have voted the same either way.

Keep up the good ideas!

Five Loaves Bakery
by holdingtime

Comment:
*Critique Club*

"Five Loaves Bakery" is a nice entry into the Window Framed challenge.

The image itself has a different subject which I think grabs attention. I really like your idea and think you have a great idea. The contrast between the green and the red also grabs attention and enhances the shot. Unfortunately the reflections that we can see in the glass take away from the overall image. Also I might have tried cropping it a little differently. I would have tried it tighter on the right side like on half way on the column. Also possibly cropped the pole on the left side out completely because it is distracting because of how uneven it looks.

Overall this was a great idea and I look forward to your future works!

History
by Tej

Comment:
*Critique Club*

"History" is an amazing entry into the Window Framed challenge. Congratulations on the excellent score and overall placement in the challenge.

The image is excellent because it is a subject that many voters are unable to see, which always makes it a rare treasure and the fact it was taken so well makes it even better. The frame you were able to use enhances the architecture of the subject with the contrast. The image does seem to be a little dark but it does look like the sun was going down which makes it pretty hard to get the right lighting. Even the lighting doesn't take away too much from the score for me.

Overall an extremely impressive shot and I am very glad you entered it. Keep up the good work.

out of the frame
by redpanda

Comment:
*Critique Club*

"Out of the frame" is a fun addition into the Window Framed challenge. I like that your subject just grabs the voters attention.

The image is a nice change because we are not looking through the window to see our subject, he/she is right there. The composition is very nice. THe frame does not take away from the subject. The focus is very nice, I love the eyes and the whiskers. The coloring is very nice and natural. I really think you did good work with the shot. Unfortunately I think a lot of voters take subject matter personally when voting, like if they don't like cats or animal photos.

Keep up the good work I look forward to your future challenges.

Hardwick Old Hall, Derbyshire
by alpharich

Comment:
*Critique Club*

"Hardwick Old Hall, Derbyshire" is a nice addition into the Window Framed challenge. I have to say congratulations on a new personal best, that is always a wonderful thing to see after the challenge ends.

The photograph itself is very interesting and did grab my attention. I think the image grabbed more of my attention because you left more of the surrounding frame in the shot unlike many of the other entries. I love the rustic appeal with the broken covering on the right-hand side. The composition is very nice. The subject framed looks so prefect it almost looks unreal. Like Konador said there is some halo on the blue in the frame that is showing up, but for me it was pretty minimal. Overall great work!

Escape from Poverty
by cislander

Comment:
*Critique Club*

"Escape from Poverty" is a wonderful addition to the Window Framed challenge. Obviously very good work, it was nice to see this image finish in the top 25%.

The idea here is just excellent and nice and out of the box thinking! I really the position of the window and how the staircase is directly in the center. Overall the composition is very pleasing. The only thing that seems to hurt the shot is the lighting which I assume is the sun. The left hand upper square looks overblown probably from the placement of the sun at this time of day.

Great work and I look forward to your future challenges.