Serpico
by jdannels

Comment:
In terms of recreation of the scene yours is right up there. Should have placed higher.

SAW
by Joey Lawrence

Comment:

Originally posted by klstover: I was so afraid this would ribbon, because now I have to stare at the thumbnail on the front page for a while! Congrats though. :-) I am so disturbed by the thoughts of the movie, and I haven't even looked at the full version of this photo - just your thumbnail alone has enough impact for me to be bothered. I hope that you will consider this a compliment, because I am truly in awe of your ability to bring this movie to the photographic medium.

LOL. I wondered about if the gross factor would prevent it from winning but I guess not. Now I will have to bookmark another page for a week. Come to think of it that's not so bad since Joey will have to see it on his front page for quite a bit longer. :P

ETA: Btw, congrats Joey.

Message edited by author 2006-09-06 01:30:22.

Washington State Ferry - Edited
by levyj413

Comment:
I like this edit especially the color on the boat. I hadn't really noticed this before but the darken edges makes it look like you are looking through this with a scope. Works well with this particular subject. Good job!

Kalina
by elemess

Comment:
There's something freaky about that thing in the background. I do like the high key aspect of the model.

at eleven II
by ErinM

Comment:
I can see why you take so many photos of her. She is SOOO photogenic as is your son. I must agree with Louis about the DOF. Masterful indeed.

Mennonite House Interior
by Fromac

Comment:
This is a crazy photo. Each room that's visible shares a common object although not necessarily the same object, which for some strange reason I find fascinating.

Voidiness
by redmoon

Comment:
I must say you did a great job in this challenge. This photo beckons anyone who sees it to "search" for the subject yet cannot find it as it is void of such. The gloomy aspect adds to that theme, IMO.

Peace of mind
by terje

Comment:
I really like this series. This isn't as good as the others but I really really don't get why people can't except the processing style you have taken with these. You either like it or you don't and move on. Saying you destroyed a photo makes zero sense especially when I'm pretty sure you still have the untouched original anyway. Sorry, it seems like I'm in my own rant but I hate when people demand a subject be presented in just one way and one way only. Kudos to you for bringing something new to a very saturated subject matter, pun intended.

Message edited by author 2006-09-04 01:17:00.

N/A
by Melethia

Comment:
I like that title. Good pic!

untitled
by Bear_Music

Comment:

Originally posted by SandyP: Gosh this is beautiful! I can't believe this one isn't a top 10 photo!

If we ran this challenge over and over each week it wouldn't surprise me if this scored between 7.2 and 5.2. I'm constantly amazed why some photos do so well and others so poorly and then seemingly reverse order when similar photos are taken in similar challenges. I guess it's like surfing. You gotta hit that wave at the right time and place except here the wave is invisible.