Fantasy Cabin
by Phom

Comment:
Get that canvas up to 640px my man! Sigh. I'm a real sucker for a good IR shot. Maybe because I haven't done any myself yet. One point off for canvas size. 7

Where is my leg?
by Magnus_i

Comment:
I think this may qualify as "bad bokeh" (if you even paid attention to that thread back on that challenge). Look at the way the highlights stand out on parts of the ducks. Not too pleasant. The absolute centered subject is a bit tough too. Doesn't speak M&M to me. 4

Surprise in my Way
by lsmart

Comment:
Nice landscape. Nice conversion from B&W. Doesn't speak a great deal of M&M to me, but the rock formations are slightly exotic. 5

God's Creation in Seven Days is a Beautiful Mystery
by asmithphotos

Comment:
Make that canvas bigger. We always want 640 pixels on one side. The shot could benefit from some PP. Shadow/highlights or hue masked to the clouds. A vertical orientation may help and I wish I had something in the foreground (beach, boat, bird, something). Perhaps I'm thinking too much of my Afterlife shot. Mildly DNMC (not enough to vote down). 4

The Magic Hour
by Jaded_Housewife

Comment:
Not bad. Somehow I want to move the horizon line, but i'm not sure where. A bit soft. I made the comment on another sunset that it was mildly DNMC, but not in a big way. 5

The Magic Tree
by Elvis_L

Comment:
A great tree. Does seem sorta mysterious. The shot does lack a certain "something" though, probably a focus (this may be a good example for "Image without subject"). 5

The Indian Rope Trick
by 3eyedcrow

Comment:
Nicely posed. Expressions and body language seems real. The B&W conversion is nice. The white T-shirt is just a bit too bright. 8

The Witch's Familiar
by ltlmschrisss

Comment:
Almost looks like a painting. I'm guessing that may be an artifact of the hue shift. I'm guessing the cat's eyes were yellow and perhaps I would have left them like that. (My apologies if they weren't). 5

Blue Light Levitation (Harry Blackstone Jr. Tribute)
by thegrandwazoo

Comment:
Nicely composed, lit and the trick is pulled off well. One nitpick is the red lighting on the gloves looks outof place since you shifted the hue of the light bulb. 7

Mother Nature's Crystal Ball
by L1

Comment:
Nice. I may have tried to lower the luminosity of the hand just a bit. My eye keeps jumping to the thumb. Looks magical enough. 7