Red Fields of Sugarcane
by sherpet

Comment:
The colors are nice, but I think the composition is a bit uninspired. 4

An Honest Day's Work
by Photologist

Comment:
Well, you have other "hand" shots to compete with. This is not quite sharp enough. I see it worst in the lower right and the pinky finger. Although we always think that non-centered is best, I would say having a bit more space on the right would be better in this shot. 5

Winter sea
by Rino63

Comment:
Well, the dirt is sorta an afterthought here isn't it? It's a nice exposure although you have quite a halo on the horizon. 5

lost
by rinac

Comment:
Nice contrasts and textures. I like this one. 7

Dirtpile At Sunset
by tomcat

Comment:
Interesting in the fractal sense that this looks like a larger mountain range, but not much beyond that. 4

A little help here?
by timfythetoo

Comment:
His expression looks a bit on the perplexed side rather than the frightened or desperate. It's a nice setup, although I also want more dirt on those arms. 6

Duck with a dirty face
by GinaRothfels

Comment:
The tones are tough on this one. I'm afaid this one lets me down a bit. I think it's the medium crop. Either really get it in there or zoom it back for some context. 4

"The Only Difference Between Men and Boys ..."
by lynnmarie

Comment:
Sigh, I discovered my camera was broken when I was at a quarry trying to shoot one of those massive dump trucks, so we were on the same page for ideas. The sunlight is a bit bright or harsh, but not too bad. I wish we could figure out a composition where we could enjoy his face as well as the juxtaposition of his toys. 5

Emerged from the dirt
by Ragga2000

Comment:
Well, he doesn't look dirty enough to have just emerged. I'm looking for real dirty. It's a nice capture though and I like the expression. 6

Dirty Window..... and a smile despite poverty
by Shy Clicker

Comment:
Colorful, but the green/teal looks pixelated from the saturation. I wish you could have cropped it so there was a row of brick at the top and the whole window was in the frame. 6