The Cigarette Monsters
by robranaldo

Comment:
7 - Good idea, colors, composition and textures are good. Criticism; perhaps a tighter crop at the bottom, to me the bottom 'butts' that are out of focus dominate the shot, that or different 'focus', because the ash and tobacco at the 'base' adds a good element in my opinion.

Thats not food.
by shadeeua

Comment:
7 - Good perspective. Criticism; would like to have seen the 'focal point' on the garbage more so and the garbage incorporated more into the frame, 'somehow'.

Breakfast for One...
by Younger

Comment:
8 - Good and creative. Criticism; perhaps a 'tidy up' ofthe coffee grains(?), not sure, might look too 'aesthetic' cleaned up though. Just needs a little 'something' to add a dramatic effect in my opinion, but no idea how or where, maybe lighting, background, not sure.

Myakka State Park
by ArpeggioAngel

Comment:
7 - Nice, and good coloring. Criticism; not much, undecided if I would like to see more 'light' on that fore tree, but I do like this 'dark' effect there too so unsure. Difficult also to tell if it is 'straight', or needs a nudge up on the right. I think just a bit more detail on the right of frame, 'around' the tree, may have made this even better.

Golden Forest
by candle

Comment:
3 - Good potential here. Criticism; should be 640 at in width &/or height, especially for this Challenge. Different crop too would have helped.

Surprise In The Bush
by KitKat

Comment:
3 - In my opinion, this is about the roo and not the 'landscape'. The potential seems to be there for a good landscape shot (with or without the kangaroo), plus what landscape is in this shot, is blurred, out of focus and, in the foreground especially, seemingly 'blown'.

Houston Woods Butler County
by Crafty Sue

Comment:
3 - I like the potential. Criticism; definitely at least 640, preferably width at least. Not sure what you did with the sat/contrast, but the tree on the left looks 'too blue', while you may have been going for a certain look/feel with that, it is not enhanced by the fact you cropped half the tree out. A different crop, slight nudge rotation up on the right and as stated 'bigger', would have made this shot much better in my opinion.

Landscape with sheeps
by Rasmus

Comment:
5 - Mostly for the potential. Criticism; like to see it at least 640 on at least one side (preferably width), but possibly height too. Not sure if you rotated this, or this is how the scene looked, but either way looks like the 'horizon' needs a slight nudge up on the left hand side. Unusual view/angle and looks like it has potential and even though the colors are fairly 'drought' stricken (seemingly), like to see a little bit more contrast or color adjustment, somehow. Frame detracts in my opinion. And, if 'sheeps' was intentional, 'ok', otherwise, 'sheep'.

Deserted docks
by InnaN

Comment:
7 - Very nice. Criticism; not much and difficult as I don't know 'what is there' either side, but perhaps a different crop, especially with less sky, may have made this even better in my opinion. Like the 'straight lines' in the docks and far 'land'/causeway.

Confluence
by alanfreed

Comment:
7 - Very nice shot. Criticism; depending what is there on the left middle/fore, I wonder how this shot would have looked with the right cropped (cutting out that road(?)/bank and incorporating more of the left side of the frame. The colors are very nice and the reflection brilliant on the fairly calm water.