Waiter!!!
by srdanz

Comment:
One of the few I thought really met the challenge. Very well composed. Focus is tack sharp and composition is excellent. Colors are well preserved and the scene is well depicted. I really like your placement for lighting. Certainly a hair in your soup is an unexpected find. Very well done! 10

Waiter... There's a Rubber Duck in my soup...
by diablo2097

Comment:
Technically this is a good shot - nice and crisp, well composed and excellent color control. The lighting is well done and the perspective is good as well. However, if you had used a real hair or had a bug floating in the soup or even the spoon with soup and the hair/bug in it THAT would be unexpected. Also, with the spoon off to the side and clean (as in obviously not used yet) doesn't help. There is no element of finding anything. If you were in an eatery the duck would have never made it out of the kitchen. But the duck, to me, sorry, just doesn't cut it. It would never be anything even remotely plausible in any eatery.

Technicals: 6
Challenge: X

Roadside River
by Jib

Comment:
There doesn't seem to be anything in focus.

green cornfield
by tendogz

Comment:
Looks more like wheat to me...

Superman Seatgrab over Vail
by Conskier2003

Comment:
I thought this was a green challenge?

Fortifications of the Future
by m

Comment:
Where is the green?

Moth On the Floor
by stare_at_the_sun

Comment:
Where is the empty room?

Where Have All The Pictures Gone
by jerryc12

Comment:
Where is the empty room?

Jasmine
by PhotoTess

Comment:
There is no indication that this is an empty room - just a person sitting on the carpet.

The Pedestal: Default Storage For D.P.Challenge!
by 777STAN

Comment:
Not sure why the title has to include the second part after the colon. Makes no sense.