Nothing small here
by Bigdad

Comment:
Surely you could of moved to your right a wee bit to help the composition here?

What could of been a good, well composed shot has been transformed into a mere snapshot.

aSpire to the Heavens
by SteveJ

Comment:
very boring and uninspiring snapshot.. meets the challenge and exposed well, but thats about it.. 5

Selfportrait On The Stairway
by rokcuder

Comment:
OK, you are quite brave posting a shot that a few voters will no doubt deem `out of focus`, but it works, it has the fell of a 1970s shot. It works well, and although YOU are in the shot, the main focus is still the ever decreasing circles of the stairwell.. its actually a better shot than some people will give it credit for..

Fall Wedding
by pixistix68

Comment:
OK, I am a wedding photographer myself so maybe I am looking at this from a wedding point of view and not a challenge point of view.. the idea is good, however the execution isnt so good. The bride looks VERY uncomfortable and not at all elegant, her position has pushed her tits right up into her face, its really isn't classy.. however, it does fit the challenge and the exposure is nice, but as a wedding shot its not something I would be showing the B+G after they return from their honeymoon. 6

Broncos stadium from the ground up.
by cathysapp

Comment:
meets the challenge and is well exposed, but other than that quite boring. 5

Iron Man
by griz210

Comment:
bit of a dull subject. a stationary piece of sculpture . and even then you managed to cut the foot off. 5

CAUTION: big chimney ahead!
by maxxumg

Comment:
very dark and not very inspiring.. 4

hélicoptère
by tcmartin

Comment:
great angle and fits the challenge well. I will say you either

a/ have an insanely long lens
b/ were standing below a VERY low flying helicopter
or c/ this is a mounted helicopter and no threat to you at all :-)

still, all in all meets the challenge perfectly, you dealt with a tricky exposure problem well (dark object against a light sky) and have thrown in a good BW conversion as well.. brilliant!! 8

reaching the sky
by Lore

Comment:
OK, you have probably heard this already, but this would of been a lot better had you straightened it (legal in basic editing) Also, adding a bit of contrast would of improved the overall feel of the shot. 5

Transparent Mushroom
by gaurav

Comment:
Hi Gaurav! This was a very interesting thumbnail and drew me in for a closer look. The DOF is super fine here, so you did well to nail the focus. This should score a new Personal best for you... 7 well done.