Daytona fun
by maryrk0904

Comment:
I have a feeling that this image does not meet basic editing rules.

However...

...comp nice, interesting art form, nice color, nice selective desat, good emotional value, light just ok,

Lets Play Ball
by rupypug

Comment:
what is special about this field?

You are not showing me anything that is giving me goose bumps.

comp could be better, color ok, horizon right smak in the middle of the image, so what, light flat to not interesting, texture?, dof is there but why? overall a boring image.

roller-blade
by clictacamera

Comment:
Tell me, why should I care for these two roller bladers?

There is nothing for me to care about. It's just a portraiture.

Comp ok, colors bland, light flat, grainy, blacks too deep, whites ok, overall boring

The Big Kick
by BeckyT

Comment:
I like this picture even though it does not run with conventional guidelines.

I would of gave you a higher vote if his hand was not in front of his face. As it is, it diminished the emotional value a bit.

Usually, a tight crop is used in sports photography, however, I think personally, unless you are selling the image to a paper or magazine, other photogrpahy rules can be applied such as this image.

Great comp, nice use of thirds, great capture, excellent color, great light, excellent dof, excellent bg, great texture, overall a great image.

Header
by MattO

Comment:
Everything that I know about sports photography tells me that this is almost a flawless image.

The only thing is the bg fence line that cuts through your player.

Great comp, great color, great capture, great emotional value, dirt blood texture nice, light a bit flat but what are ya going to do?, It's not bad however, great shallow dof focusing on the players only, just excellent over all.

Pets enjoy sports as much as we do.
by Daybis

Comment:
Prove to me that pets enjoy sports as we do, and I will give you a life time of 10's.

I am not convinced.

comp ok, color ok, texture ok, blacks a bit deep, whites ok, nice dof, nice use of thirds, crisp

Don't give up, just do better.

Sports Watch
by Fairfield20

Comment:
Why do you want me to care for this image?

I am not convinced that it is a sports watch. It is highly pixelated, the color sucks, the lighting sucks, I can barely make anything out of this.

Don't give up, just do better.

Little League ~ Mom's View
by okiesisi

Comment:
Mom...

...why do I want to care for your sons backside? the very least you could of done was to have him turn and let me see his big beautiful smile.

The fence line is distracting as well. The colors are ok, the light is flat, texture is ok, comp sucks, dof good...

...come on mom, this is your son. Ya want to show him off don't ya, well, do so next time.

Don't give up, just do better.

100m dash
by Mark

Comment:
First of all, when I think of sports, I think of humans.

Even if an animal is included, there should be a human.

Secondly, this comp sucks. I can care less for the rear end of an animal. The far left tail could of been at the very least cleaned up and cropped out. the color is ok, image could be crisper, light is flat, texture ok.

Don't give up, just do better.

Running for Money
by johst582

Comment:
Sorry, I am not going to go as far as to say DNMC. However, I do think that this is a lazy attempt to shoe horn something into a challenge just because you can.

I am not convinced that this is sports related. Not going to waste my time on a good critique.