Dun romin
by horsemadgirl

Comment:
Strongest point - texture. What could have been improved - the lighting.. I give it a 9

Gone But Not Forgotten
by SJCarter

Comment:
Thing I liked most - The lighting on this one. Thing I liked the least - Not very focused. Framing could have been done more cleanly. The second tree to the left makes the image out of balance.

vinyl
by buzzmom

Comment:
Obsolete, it is indeed. But the composition is too compressed. I'll bet if you did it more square, and had the lines of the record forming a semicircle on one side,, it would have presented better.

rusted chain
by umbranimbus

Comment:
I like the framing of the chain in the green circle behind it. You also left a nice shadow in the image. Very well done.

The Age of Steam
by p2jvr

Comment:
All lines lead to the train. Nice composition. The only thing that might have improved the picture is doing it in landscape format rather than portraiit. The train is too compressed in the image. By the way, I've found that because of our editiing ability, all photos don't even have to be a traditional rectangle. They can be square as well.

Refrigerator c1900 - in full working order
by Imagineer

Comment:
I really learned something from this shot. I had no idea that at one time such a structure was used to keep things cool. Your detail is really nice, and the moss on the brick puts its age into perspective. Lighting is dim which adds a softness to your image. I give it a 9

remember cutting and pasting?
by lakritstroll

Comment:
Scrapbooking is really hot right now. This is if anything right in line with what is happening today in the craft world as well as the world of photography. I work in retail and this type of stuff in this photo makes up around 30% of our weekly sales.

Obsolete Transportation can be a Real Drag
by netdude

Comment:
Thuis was too cute. Compoitionally it would have been better positioned if the horse had room in front of him to actually walk.

Maybe, maybe not
by squamata

Comment:
I think the angle is too straight on. You should have moved up some to get more of the record and the arm playing it.

A door to history
by Ronce

Comment:
The door is not presented as the strongest subject. The grass is. As a picture, I love it. I think you did a very nice shot. However, for this challenge, it doesn't say enough about being obsolete.