500 Boylston
by Yellowpeep

Comment:
I didn't vote on this challenge, so I have nothing to compare this image to, but it sure looks good to me. Anyway, I have a feeling that one of the reasons it did not do better is because the foreground sign seemed to compress the photo, rather than stay with the wide angle idea. I especially like the curves of the building, and would have liked to see more of the right one as a balance to the left curve.

Riverside Bench
by tsheets

Comment:
I looked at this one and Silverside Boat. I think this one is the better of the two. I like the compositional placement of the bench in conjunction with the horizon. The sky is much nicer on this one also.

Gardenias
by Eagle Eye

Comment:
Didn't like the grain on this one.

Roll Your Own
by TiN

Comment:
Didn't think there was any white on this one. It looks basically yellow.

Jack
by MudHut

Comment:
Loved the swirling light. Very well executed. You took a simple carving and created an awesome image by surrounding it with interesting compositional items. Nice job.

Into The Orange Light
by xlr8tn

Comment:
Like the abstract nature of this one. Needed to reduce the noise, though. It realy is strong around the candle and the edges of the black.

Trick or Treat
by rwouthuis

Comment:
Traditional to the max. Loved the use of the candy in this one. Very good image for Halloween and composition is perfect. A little too much noise, though in the lit up faces.

HOWEEEEEN!
by Nald

Comment:
Carving is extradinary and intricate. The lighting doesn't seem to be creating enough impact, though. I also thought the corn didn't do much to enhance the pumpkins.

Fire Eyes
by Links 2 3 4

Comment:
Very cool effect.

Burn Face
by m--E

Comment:
Really the most that is gross in this challenge. I think the flame on the right didn't get depicted as well as it could. Not sure how to get it looking more like a flame. I am still trying to figure that one out successfully.