DisAdvantix
by TrollMan

Comment:
Beautiful background. I think that the film was added just to meet the challenge. I hope you have this image without the film canister. That really wrecked it for me.

Smokers Life
by Akasha

Comment:
I am sure you have already been told that the image did not fill the frame. Beyond that, it was badly focused, and you should try to remove the date which appears in the lower left before submitting. These are all things that can be remedied as you take more pictures. The mistakes will become less and less, then you have to deal with things like composition, subject attractiveness, and all those variables which people vote on.

Reflections of an Onion Skin
by sfalice

Comment:
This was a really great reflection. I loved the blue background and its contrast to the onion skin. Lighting was very good as well. 10

Busy Architecture
by KarenNfld

Comment:
Absolutely beautiful.

smog city
by melodee

Comment:
Nice angle. Needed a bit more contrast.

Communication
by fallingretina

Comment:
Wiring is a good subject to show busy, but this seemed very rough. The photo did not come out very smooth, though your sky is very well exposed.

'been busy all day....Take a break!
by viktors

Comment:
The shot seemed out of focus.

Branches
by xlr8tn

Comment:
Seemed overprocessed. I am seeing some strange colors in the background light. There is quite a bit of bad light balance here. Perhaps an exposure compensation at the time of the shot might have helped, as well as adding a neutral density filter to balance the light better. If your camera doesn"s allow a filter, buy one anyway and hold it in front of the camera. It should still give the same result.

Design Awry
by banmorn

Comment:
It must have taken hours to cut all these shapes. For the trouble you had to put in to the photo, I give it an 8. It is definitely very busy, though the foreground seems somewhat dark, but it could be my monitor.

Rescue
by mawear

Comment:
This was a wow photo. I know it is basic editing and you can't do any kind of burning or dodging, but I see the photo as you can edit it without restrictions, so I give it a 10.