Final Push
by Falc

Comment:
I like this photo very much. I have been holding off on judging it because I just don't know how it fits with the challeng so here I go trying to make sense of it all.

Artistic...............7 I like all the activity in the frame and how the whole frame is being used. Lots of strong lines moving my eyes and keeping me interested

Technical......7 The overall exposure of the image is very balanced, no real big problems in seeing detail in the lightest or darkest areas. Photo doesn't seem to have come from a digital camera, believe me this is a plus as I don't like images that are over processed or photos that have focus that is "hyper".

Meets challenge description....this is the one I have been trying to deal with for the past few days with this image.....My first response to this image was that I didn't see anybody in this photo making any decision, it appears that this is one of those mindless acts of "group think", that all these worriers are just pushing foreward because the other guy in front of him was told to go foreward so if he goes I will follow.....I suppose that is a decision.....so you get a ....6 for meeting the challenge.

Average 6 but I'll push you up to 7 because I haven't seen anything in this challenge that has this subject or quality combined......

Choosing Pathways
by gotrond

Comment:
Nice image not sure if it meets the challenge.

The First Step
by eyesightphoto

Comment:
very nice image

Red or White?
by AlexMonty

Comment:
Without title this image is more about wine and lighting.....

He Loves Me, He Loves Me Not
by marmalade1121

Comment:
Technical......5
Artistic.....5
Meets challenge....6
Average 5

Last bite options
by 4score

Comment:
Technical......5
artistic.......5
Meets challenge discription.......2

average 4

Should I take the next one out of the country?
by benhur

Comment:
I am not considering titles in this challenge.

Does image meet challenge description........1
Technical.......4 The image is a bit on the dark side. Better Processing may correct this
artistic........5.......I like the placement of the plane in the frame

Average 3

Hold 'em or Fold 'em
by joansuzy

Comment:
Technical.......5
Artistic........4
Meets challenge discription...........4 Without title I don't know what you are saying to the viewer.

Average 3 rounded to 4

Financial Decisions
by RolandB

Comment:
May fit challenge descrption 5
Technical......5
Artistic.....5

average 5......

The bravery!!
by jensmustang

Comment:
I think this subject works within the challenge description, but the image needs some work in the focusing, it appears that the day was overcast so I guess the lighting is flat because of the lack of proper lighting. Nice try subject wise though, and I like the framing.