Underground
by fredandaud

Comment:
You must obtain the permission of the station supervisor before taking any photos of the underground... how often has that tap on my shoulder ruined a good long exposure.

Very nice image. I like the slightly unfocussed and grainy quality - a real black & white feel to this. It feels as though the image is spiralling. 9.

Dove on Roof
by Zed Pobre

Comment:
Good capture - classic rooftop shot. Very slight lack of detail in the area around the chest and RHS of bird - very slight jaggies, plus very slight halo makes me wonder if a fraction less sharpening might improve. I might also have made the blue of the sky a little more intense, to capture the contrast with the orange light on the bird's chest. Central composition is fine, but I would experiment with variations on the third lines, and if printing large, with a "minimalist" style shot of this bird and a nice big, plain sky above and a wider crop..

Tree and Lights in Fog (2)
by Zed Pobre

Comment:
This is an interesting photo, that I might have taken with quite a bit of underexposure to retain more detail. While I like the idea of glare through tree tops, there is perhaps a little more than I would choose in this photo. I would have experimented with a smaller aperture and longer exposure (still retaining underexposure), which , I think, would retain detail in the darker elements and possibly the light sources. This would give greater flexibility for post processing.

On this screen (admittedly lacking a little in brightness - but cranked up to the max), the top of the photo has lost too much detail to be interesting (faded to black) - though that could be my monitor. Curves in PS might be used to increase the contrast in that part of the spectrum.

Bad old Puddytat waiting for the birds
by Xilebo

Comment:
interesting, but black cat barely qualifies as a silhouette! blends in with background in parts.more contrast required.

A Bridge Away From Capitol City
by neophyte

Comment:
not sure what the focus here is - lacking in focal point.

painting works
by rhipster

Comment:
barely a silhouette. Interesting, though - would like to see side profile of face for more interest, and something being done with left arm.

Window Dressing
by photogenix

Comment:
pretty image, but missing real interest. Foreground might be better isolated by narrower DoF.

Young Adonis
by msdoubletrouble

Comment:
pose is not great for silhouette - other arm is missing, not much detail in profile of face, shoes blurry and blending into floor (needs more contrast).

Chopper Overhead
by Pug-H

Comment:
compositionally, I might have cropped slightly more and moved the chopper closer to a third line. good capture, but not interesting enough by itself in a strong field.

Windmill
by spydr

Comment:
another windmill... ! overexposure of sun looks ugly. rest of silhouetted subject is too close to sky colours - needs more contrast to stand out.