Light and shadow
by Melethia

Comment:
like the play of light and shadow. Image feel slightly off balance but not sure why. toning echo well done. 7

Too late for "Window Framed"?
by Rgarcia

Comment:
framing adds. Sharp, composed well, excellent timing for expression. 7

The incredible lightness of being...
by pphuang

Comment:
for me, the lighting makes this shot. Composition well done, colors rendered well. 8

Heaven and Earth
by Artifacts

Comment:
love the flow and textures. colors play well. 8

Seed
by MudHut

Comment:
strong compositionally. would like just a touch more contrast. flows with interesting lighting. 8

White on White: Egret Displays
by sfalice

Comment:
back and forth on this one. strong graphic elements but the composition is a little weak. or is it the colors? none-the-less, interesting. 8

daydream
by CalliopeKel

Comment:
Well deserved - It should have come sooner! Excellent concept and follow through.

Picasso Jr. (Picasso by Irving Penn)
by gsal

Comment:
Wow. I can't believe I didn't mark this as a favorite when I first saw it. Must have been in a hurry. Still in love with this. It proves that you can completely ignore the 'rules of composition and lighting' and produce an amazingly wonderful emotive image. Maybe I love it because it breaks the rules - I'm not a rules gal anyway. Geez I love this image. Well done.

At the Butcher's
by e301

Comment:
Okay, I'll say it, you was robbed. This should have been first. So, what happened next? Are you going to make me buy the book? :)

House
by alexgarcia

Comment:
Take Ed's advice - he is right on the money. My own thoughts? Showing this much building, its disturbing that there is no ground. I know its there - the door ends. As it is, I get the sense that I'm nowhere - I don't have anything to stand on to view this image. The texture of the sky is great, but in this image it fights with the texture of the walls for attention. The corner of the building cuts this image nearly perfectly in two. I think you need to decide what drew you to the building and concentrate on that. If it is the building as a whole, pull out and show us the surroundings so we get a sense of place. You have the eye to find interesting things; now you have to decide what is most interesting and focus on that. I am very intrigued by the wheel in the window - I want more. Maybe this building is many images of parts rather than one image of the whole.