Milk's Perfect Form
by myqyl

Comment:
Good original idea and 100% on topic for the challenge. The composition and lighting are just a bit weak. P.S. I love Cadbury.

Failed "Got Milk?" Ad Campaign
by hardwaybets

Comment:
X-rated moo cows! LOL very cute but why the blanket/cover on the left? Privacy? A levels adjustment would of helped here, but the focus is nice and your sure on the challenge.

Spilled
by Gracious

Comment:
Lucky kitty. This shot is a good idea.
The execution is weak and the focus are soft.
I understand the challenge of shooting cats! [See my profile.] Ya take what ya get. Because of the clever idea, the hardship of animals ...............and that you had to clean up the milk....I give you an 8. Also the colors are good and you fit the challenge 110%. :)

Alaskan Landscape
by bdshort

Comment:
Alaska took two ribbons......congrats!!!
Print and frame this one.

Reflections Under Ice
by gminish

Comment:
Congrats to you! Beautiful blue.

When was the last time you watered the plants, dear?
by jjbeguin

Comment:
Congrats on the ribbon. Hope ya water them plants. :)

OW! I HATE It When That Happens!!!
by albright1

Comment:
Fun shot Ivy, really a good, creative shot. FUNNY.
Bravo.

Un-Forbidden Fruit
by autool

Comment:
I'm so glad you didn't resist this funny shot.
Great job.CONGRATS

Message edited by author 2003-01-20 00:08:06.

Fountains in the Desert, Las Vegas
by Gordon

Comment:
CC: Hello
Interesting composition-It can sure be said that Las Vegas can be _strange_! These people are all stangers in the desert looking at water shoot 50 feet or more in the air.
Composition/Content-Very good composition with good balance. I would only of cropped out the tree on the right. That also would of removed the distracting white light up on the top corner. Still both are so minor that it's not important to the overall photo. The best feature of this shot is that you can't see these peoples faces. They remain 'strangers'.
Digital Processing-Perfect because I don't see any.
Fits The Challenge-100%+
My Opinion On The Photo-I hope you can tell I like it. It's odd to me reading the comments that many didn't see how this fit the challenge. No, matter because they liked the photo too. Well done Gordon as all your work. Thanks for the opportunity to review this super photograph.

Witchita Lineman, by Glen Campbell
by spiderman

Comment:
CC
Greetings Spiderman
Interesting composition-

Composition/Content-Interesting subject, title.

Background-Beautiful rich blue.

Digital Processing - Sharp, crisp, clean shot. Good focus, light, shadow, color and exposure.

Fits The Challenge- 100% and with humor.

My Opinion On The Photo- I didn't fall out of my chair when I first saw it during the challenge. I did however like the clean, clear, crisp look and gave it a 7. I would of voted it higher but then and now I think the crop is wrong. It's either that we need more at the top or more width. I hope that makes sense I will say your lens is very good I can clearly see the pigeon. The large/white 'transformer' is just a distraction.