Bricks
by aidanthetoo

Comment:
Great job on your first challenge, Aidan!

Jungle Patterns
by timfythetoo

Comment:
Get any closer and you're gonna be lunch. :-) Nice work through glass, and seems to have appealed to the voters as well. I'll confess I didn't vote in this one, but it would have scored well from me. First I'm a sucker for animals, second, I love the detail.

Going up!
by timfythetoo

Comment:
Rowan this time! Not sure about the desat, but reading your explanation, I can understand why you did it. I don't mind "busy" when it serves a purpose, and it doesn't bother me here at all. In fact it serves as kind of a neat contrast - all the busy hard lines and and metal and plastic edges comtrasted with a lovely little girl and her concentration.

Papaya Seeds or Mantis Eggs?
by timfythetoo

Comment:
This poor guy is probably getting very tired of seeing the inside of your refrigerator. I'm surprised he hasn't moved to the neighbor's yard yet! But you do a very good job of shooting him (or her, as the case may be.) Nice setup, nice shot, nice score, nice finish.

...
by timfythetoo

Comment:
Extremely good clone work on this! I've been going back and forth between the original and the finished one and I'm quite in awe of what you were able to do. My only suggestion - take it back into PS and tone down the yellows a lot and the reds a bit in hue/sat and see if you like it better. Great score and great finish, even if Aimee did beat you. :-)

Station to Station
by Rae-Ann

Comment:
Woman, this rocks! I didn't vote in this challenge and to tell you the truth, forgot to look through the results. AWESOME score and great finish! But that's neither here nor there. I absolutely love the picture. I love the desat and the yellow. And I really love that it's a "shot from the hip" kinda thing. My kinda picture, and you did it really, really, really well! Really well!

Northern Night
by Louis

Comment:
Hey, you entered a challenge! :-) I'm trying to think of the artist/print this reminds me of, but I'll never come up with it. But whatever it is, it really reminds me of that. I very much like this and cannot think of a single thing I'd want changed. Tones, composition, exposure are all dead on. Very nicely done, and underrated.

White Dahlia
by chalice

Comment:
Gorgeous! I LOVE the way it moves from the blown corner in the upper left down to the pure softness and the eye travels. Nicely composed, well exposed. Very nice shot all around! (I won't judge as to "abstract" or "macro" since I have a grasp on neither.)

Halving the Seed
by chalice

Comment:
I like how the seed is hinted at - peeking out. Nice job of a solid, supporting background, as well, and the DOF is good to get both halves of the apple focused. I think I'd have preferred to see the face of the apple at just a bit more of an angle, though, rather than dead on towards the camera - it would add a bit more texture that way.

Fishing
by chalice

Comment:
A perfect kind of shot for this challenge - meets the description but has interest - something more than just a tree. May be a tad on the darkish side. A quick check in Photoshop shows you could add a little using levels and/or curves to bring out the colors/detail more. Excellent composition overall.