Take Flight
by Cutter

Comment:
Cool freeze action shot. Not sure that it's really framed as suggested in the challenge description, but it's an interesting study in motion.

One old barn to another...
by cislander

Comment:
Looks like a fun place to just look around, and a fine location for some interesting isolated shots probably. This photo is technically fine, and meets the challenge. I do find my eyes wondering looking for a place to settle in...there's so much to look at, yet no firm subject to hold my attention. JMO of course. Good luck.

The Tunnel
by haze

Comment:
I like the reflections. It adds a lot to this photo for lighting and interest.

triangle of flames
by dulfingurl

Comment:
This is a fun choice for framing. You did a good job of controlling the light of the fire. I wonder if heat shimmer is why the framing logs look a bit blurred?

View Across the Water
by ErikV

Comment:
It's hard to find good items to use for framing. That's what made this challenge so challenging IMO. Yes, the trees do frame the city in the background, but they don't really add anything to the impact of the photo. If they had leaves, maybe...as is, not really. Not trying to be overly critical, just leaving some thoughts on first impressions. Best of luck to you in the challenge.

Tree-framed Road
by Hendry Jacoby

Comment:
This works ok. The image is a little on the small side and you lose impact when compared to others in the challenge. Did you look at this in B&W? I think it would make a stronger presentation. JMO of course. Good luck in the challenge.

Pectol's Pyramid, Capitol Reef National Park
by Nald

Comment:
Very nice scene and a nice variation on framing from what I've seen thus far. May have pushed the saturation a little too much as I find the blue/cyans a bit heavy. Adjust the saturation down on those colors and see how it looks. Exposure for this scene is challenging with the extreme highlights. Couple of areas are totally blown out (lost detail). All JMO of course. :-) Good luck in the challenge.

Suburban Oasis
by Pick001

Comment:
Oh man. Why didn't you move in about 7 or 8 steps closer? You have a decent subject item here, but the foreground grass is really taking away from the overall impact of the presentation. Another option/choice would have been to use a split ND filter upside down to control the light on the grass (polarizer instead perhaps?). Lots of light reflecting off those grass blades. Just some observations. Good luck!

The Pier, Full frame or Multi.
by BrianR

Comment:
The framed subject is kind of a small piece of the composition I think. You did a great job controlling exposure as the clouds really pop out. The upper leaves and the rocks would have made a decent frame by themselves...the fence/posts I find somewhat distracting.

Hog's Back Falls in winter
by rdebruyn

Comment:
That's a strong looking waterfall - powerful. As a photography subject in the winter it's "ok". I think what you tried to do here, with including the sides (for the framing part of the challenge, yes?), makes the image somewhat cluttered IMO. Fencing, back concrete, etc...take away from the power of the water. JMO of course. Good luck in the challenge.