In Ice, Light, and Shadow
by colorcarnival

Comment:
I really like this. Not sure why. I think maybe it's the competing diagonals (branches vs shadows). You have framing in here, albeit non-traditional, that could be too subtle for many. Hope that doesn't hurt your score too much. I've picked this for my top 3...good luck getting there! :) Well done.

Outside my Window
by riversong

Comment:
Hey. Now how cool is that?! :-) Nice catch. I'd have been tempted, after getting this shot, to switch to burst mode and whistle. See what you get on the reaction. :-P Good luck in the challenge.

Peaceful Stream
by jrmyrnsm

Comment:
Here's a couple of trees that work ok for framing. :) Looks like a pretty scene. I'm losing a sense of depth perception somewhat. I think it's because the tree on the right is not giving a clear break and is blending in? I'm a fan of B&W and this may have been the best approach, no idea without seeing it in color. I do wonder tho if color would have given more depth to this. Just some observations. Still a lovely image. Good luck in the challenge.

Voyeurism
by winkeh

Comment:
Must have been a man that last used the toilet...the seat's up! :-P Clever idea for the challenge. The slightly soft image gives a sense of being there as well, instead of being crisp/sharp. May have wanted to cool the color temp just a tad as it has a strong yellowish tint from the lights. Not a big deal, just an observation. Good luck in the challenge with this.

Soup's on
by jjsmom

Comment:
Ok. It's framed...kinda. Quite a busy image with all those intersecting lines.

It's a cold day
by Alain

Comment:
Postcard type framing. Very nice. At first glance I thought this was IR, then I realized it's the REAL deal - not fake looking white snow. Cool! :-)

The Happening
by bobgaither

Comment:
They're certainly checking you out, eh? :) I have no idea how this could have been done any differently under basic editing rules, and please don't take offense to this. The image overall, because of the grey skies I guess, has a flat dull feel to it. I understand you wanted to include the incoming birds, which I probably would have as well...it's just so greyish.

I would like to see more detail on the foreground birds. The detail is lost because of distance and the high contrast lighting on them.

Don't know if it was possible (appears you may have been crouched down, but this shot a little more elevated and tighter on the birds would have kept the framing, lost some of the grey sky, and brought the birds in closer for a better look. All JMO of course. :-) Good luck in the challenge.

The Tenth Frame
by Tammer

Comment:
This is interesting in the color tones used. Seems a bit oversharpened.

Dirty Entrance
by spencerwood

Comment:
I keep tilting my head to see this straight. :) I take it the framing is the small area of wood top right and right?

I have, everybody has, they love it.
by SureShots

Comment:
Everybody has what? Not getting it, sorry. As for the photo it's certainly framed correctly. The subject(s) in the background are interesting in that I wonder what they're up to.