Past Reflections
by nikoner

Comment:
I know this is a small point, but it's a shame about the top right corner; the grass edge and the other vehicle just drag the eye away from the central subject. I think you should have cropped out the offending area or taken the car to a more suitable location. Right, moan over; apart from that, it's a great idea and I love the car and the fluffy dice just add the magic touch… (7)

Hey, who's that handsome dude?
by notashamd

Comment:
10... Fantastic shot

The Old Meeting House
by snoopy

Comment:
This is a nice shot, but I think that the wide central column draws the eye away from the reflection; seems to affect the balance of the foreground / background images. Perhaps taking the picture from an angle such that the column wasn't visible would have given a slightly better result. (5)

Reflections on driving.
by lina

Comment:
This looks like a person with the head of a dog. It's great in that respect, and I can't fault the shot – it's actually quite amusing… But, the mirror in the shot voids the challenge aspect; in terms of picture quality it's fine… Sorry to be so negative (3)

Reflecting Flower
by arnit

Comment:
Well lit, superb composition, great colour, great shot… I think the lighting is the icing on the cake with this one… (10)

Sunset
by Jacko

Comment:
Superbly done… (10)

Improvise
by Marsha

Comment:
Nice idea; B&W works really well. Also, I like the way you have handled the background. It blends really well and holds the balance in tact. The only real fault – and this is perhaps a little pedantic – is the area around the lid; it seems a little busy and that could draw the eye away from the central subject… Overall, great shot… (8)

Party Favors
by hokie

Comment:
I think the white background doesn't work. It sucks the eye away from the subject area rather than pushing it into it. Perhaps a black, or even a dark red, would have set the shot better. Composition is fine, no problem there. Sorry to sound so negative… (5)

christafari
by johnny_justjohnny

Comment:
Interesting idea, but I don't think it works too well composition wise. Yes, it's a reflection; but I don't think there's enough of it. The water, which I assume is the prime subject, is – in my opinion – lost to all the distractions around the table that draw the eye away from the central subject. The lighting is a little dull and he focus is slightly soft. I think that cropping the image to only show the blue of the table, the bottom half of the picture, would have worked much better. Sorry to be so negative… (2)

Visions
by stephan

Comment:
OK, it looks like an illegal filter, however, I shall assume otherwise because it's still here. This is quite superb all said and done, and regardless of how it was achieved, it's still a first class artistic shot. There is a lot of emotion and even though the reflection in the eye itself is undefined, this shot still works – and very well. Good shooting (10)