black and white
by visaksen

Comment:
Nice idea, but the image isn't BW. You could also work on execution, as the topmost pointer is too far on the edge to work well together witht the lower one.

Deep in Thought
by bjc0001

Comment:
Hair is very sharp, but skin seems blurred. Both have nice tones. Name doesn't match the image as it is.

Pebbles
by SteveJ

Comment:
Highlighted stone, with interesting form, is a bit blown, and shadows don't show too much detail.

Old Barn
by Jeileen

Comment:
Killing contrast might work better if the roof would be distinguishable from the woods. If this wasn't shot on film, try to find contrast from different channels (I guess green would display some difference on roof and woods). Otherwise I like the contrast, as the detail is still present. Composition is a bit odd on bottom, and there's feeling the image is not straight even though it might be.

Lookin' West
by hillbilly_jeeper

Comment:
This image is seriously missing shades. Composition is very original, the wires wouldn't bother too much but extra diagonal component on right is probably too much. The sun is partially blocked which is weird. Can't say I don't like the idea, but this execution isn't succesful to my eyes.

Tree Hugger
by riotspyne

Comment:
I wouldn't guess the tree is the main subject like it seems hinted by the focus. Look is touching even though tones at eye seem to be pretty blocked. So the contrast is not where it should be.

One Day Old - Wild Atlantic Grey Seal Pup
by Falc

Comment:
Very kind subject! :) Tones are utilized incompletely, though this isn't low key either. There's some "trash" like the hey on bottom.

School Colors
by CraigD

Comment:
Subject is dull, and lighter tones are missing.

BUCHE (Korean fan)
by docpjv

Comment:
Form is nice, and light seems to do it's job. Cropping is odd, regarding repeating form on the bottom, and partly cropped marks on left.

Trainwheels
by scottaub

Comment:
Subject is clear, form mentioned in assigment is present in multiple variations. I'm not sure the triangle at top adds anything useful. Main areas are quite contrasty, so maybe softer light would have been better.