Heartbroken
by Tranquil

Comment:
Composition: 8, Technical: 8, Appeal: 9, Challenge: 9, Overall Calculated Average Score: 9
One of very few "broken emotion" type themes that I like. This is done well - sepia and graininess adds to the effect. Only thing missing from the composition is an item that might indicate the source of her heartache. Not critical, though.

Old and broken
by JohannesFrank

Comment:
Composition: 4, crop + angle = headache
Technical: 6
Appeal: 3
Challenge: 3, rusted, but not broken
Overall Score: 3 (weighted)

Piggy
by kyebosh

Comment:
Composition: 7, The left side of the shot is obviously screaming for coins!
Technical: 8, great focus, dof, but lighting might be brighter on the right
Appeal: 7
Challenge: 7
Overall Score: 7 (weighted), Show me the money! ;-)

"Broken"
by tfarrell23

Comment:
Composition: 6
Technical: 6
Appeal: 4
Challenge: 4
Overall Score: 5 (weighted), Yes, they're broken, but two items is excessive imho

Pain in the Neck
by smellyfish1002

Comment:
Composition: 6, too tight - almost cropped out the "broken" part
Technical: 8, good shot - lighting, focus
Appeal: 7
Challenge: 5, just cracked - not broken enough for me. ;-)
Overall Score: 5 (weighted)

Ouch, no serviceable parts inside!
by graphicfunk

Comment:
Composition: 9, Technical: 10, Appeal: 10, Challenge: 10, Overall Score: 10 (weighted)
I see where it says the photo has been validated, but...??? I am dying to hear how this was done!

Oops
by scottwilson

Comment:
Composition: 6, not liking the angle
Technical: 9, Great lighting and focus
Appeal: 7, seems to be missing some motion or drama
Challenge: 8
Overall Score: 7 (weighted), Nice idea and pretty well done.

Broken Beauty
by ccasey

Comment:
Composition: 4, need to see the break
Technical: 7, nice lighting and colors
Appeal: 6
Challenge: 4
Overall Score: 6 (weighted), Suggestion: shorter stem, include the break in the shot

Fractured Reflection
by samtrundle

Comment:
Composition: 7, Technical: 7, Appeal: 7, Challenge: 2, Overall Score: 3 (weighted)
Nothing broken, but decent shot

Happy glass
by Prime_Time

Comment:
Composition: 8
Technical: 7
Appeal: 7, Very interesting
Challenge: 7
Overall Score: 7 (weighted)