Yo Ho Ho
by joebok

Comment:
Interesting. Nice Background. The crop is a bit too high IMO. I'd have cropped it under the shadow of the uppermost sail. 7.

A fine device
by jjbeguin

Comment:
Nice detail and lovely colours. Look really old and rusty. We might compare our entries after the challenge. I'll PM you. 8.

A New Day
by photom

Comment:
Nice. One of the few shots which shows the mechanics of a clock without opening it. I had to tell other who sent in a watch or clock that I don't like the way they want the viewer to anticipate the mechanics inside. You did a good job showing the pendulum in movement. 7.

mechanics of motion
by tazza

Comment:
The red colour is too vivid, and the metal elements are not visible enough. The link with the challenge is well chosen, though. 6.

Simplicity
by tyt2000

Comment:
Good use of negative space. I like the b&w and the shallow background. A bit too simple maybe. 6.

Back to the Old Days
by Tiberius

Comment:
he picture is too dark, there's not enough detail in the black surface. I know that's the way the camera is. You might have concentrated on the adjustment wheels and the shutter. 5.

Clockwork Violet
by BKerr

Comment:
Nice title, but I see just the clock, not the clockwork. It doesn't really meet the challenge. 3.

Baitcaster X-ray
by pahl

Comment:
Cool, how did you get an X-ray shot of this? There are no X-ray filters for cams, are there? I guess you work at an airport or something. I don't know what a baitcaster is but it looks cool.. The colours are kinda psychedelcic, but I like the orange blue-contrast. There's just too much 'empty' spae around the two (?) objects. 7.

Black Beauty
by Albireo

Comment:
Cool. This looks really mechanic. The colours are just right, there's some orange rust which goes well with the many shades of black. I like the detail you got into it. The crop is interesting, the wheel looks dynamic, the off-center composition adds a lot to the picture. 10.

Hands Required
by Prime_Time

Comment:
Uh, what is this? I can't imagine what this belongs to. But it looks mechanical enough to me.
You have quite a large empty area at the top of your picture. You might have just cropped it away as it doesn't contain any interesting elements.
I like the detail on the lever, it has got a nice texture. 5.