Darkman
by LeeD

Comment:
I love this shot, very clever idea and a unique way to go for this challenge. I like the lighting, its just enough to see him and whats going on, yet its little enough to keep some mystery.

Close call
by scotthadl

Comment:
I love this shot, very creative, clean well done

Under The Bridge
by LandzEnca

Comment:
I dont find this host very interesting, perhapse if it was centered and cropped a bit to remove the lower inch of the shot where noting is going on wit would have improved the image more.

65% Dark, 35% Light
by incubus

Comment:
I am not a big fan of this the bar that is seperated is too dark and hard to read the hersheys logo on it. I dont like that I can see the wood table through the white cloth perhapse a solid sheet or cloth wuld work better. The lighing is also off the piece up front is lit but the rest are not.

Smoke-black and white... now... colour!
by Cboydrun

Comment:
Although this is a nice smoke shot, my inturpretation of this challenge is to take a shot in color and make it seem like it was taken in b&w,

Untitled
by emerygirl25

Comment:
This is very uninteresting to me. The cup is fading into the background, the focus is very soft, and the lighting is washing it out.

Lost in the gray city
by kiskat

Comment:
I didnt really see this fitting in this challenge, the composition is a bit off for me. The pole seems to be as much a focus as the 2 people. The idea is sound but I think the exicution needs work. Definatly worth trying again though.

Old Black and White
by Phoenix-5

Comment:
I felt this challenge was to recreate a b&w photo, that aside I dont find this shot very interesting to look at. If you were going to include color, I would like them to be very string, everything has this muted feeling to it. the composition needs work as well, I would like to see it tighter and not see the floor and white object behind the chair on the left.

"Caesar's Profile"
by martinkulik

Comment:
This was a good idea with a lot of potential, but I dont think the contrast between the smoke and the background is strong enough. It seems more like an incidental snapshot that a planned styalized photograph.

"There is no gray."
by johst582

Comment:
I feel the spirit of this challenge was to recreate a b&w image, that being said im not a big fan of this shot, I find it difficult to look at, the composition is not doing anything for me either.