Library in Autumn
by adamweb

Comment:
The focus seems a little off and the highlights are a bit blown out. Honestly I don't think this image lends itself very well to a triptych. There is no natural separation where you have chosen to break the image and the gray/brown background doesn't help either.

"Window Panes..."
by tfarrell23

Comment:
Spectacular image. I'm not real fond of the white background though.

Which Door?
by rex

Comment:
Hmm... same image with three separate processing techniques. I'll have to say, I'm not a huge fan of the repetitive image (personal taste). The white background also seems to make the overall composition very busy to me.

U3
by Artan

Comment:
Uhm is that ewe 3? Really I like the image and title. Good overall composition.

Change
by TooCool

Comment:
Nice choice. The background is a little too busy for my taste. Maybe if the background image were darker with a little less contrast, it might help. Overall I like the image though!

Pre-Game
by alanfreed

Comment:
I like the yellows and reds. Your use of color really ties the images together.

Looking For Mr. Snake-Eyes
by hokie

Comment:
Interesting shot. The first image is a little blurry, but I like it. It adds to the sense of motion.

Sunset, Wellfleet — November 2005
by Bear_Music

Comment:
Great shot Robert!!! Congrats on a solid finish in such a huge challenge. I must admit I would've liked to see you ribbon in this particular challenge.

Stormy Seas at Dawn
by DrAchoo

Comment:
WOO-HOOO!!!! Big Fat Way To Go there Doc!!! I've been following your work pretty closely, I'm very glad to see you ribbon on this one!!

Fairy Falls Outtake
by DrAchoo

Comment:
Great shot Doc! This is a great example of a "centered" shot working very well. The shutter speed is perfect and gives a very surreal feel to the image. I am a huge fan of "misty falls" pictures. The greens also add an interesting element of color to the image. Did you shoot this on shutter-priority, aperture-priority, or manual? I think the shot is very well composed, but my only nitpick is the borderline/slightly blown highlights at the top of the waterfall. A little tweaking with the aperture/shutter speed in manual would've easily fixed that. Personally if I were voting on this image I would easily give it an 8, maybe higher.