fish love
by brad177

Comment:
Not too fond of this picture. It seems off and colourless. Its clearly fishes, so there is nothing surreal about it. The composition on the other hand is quite nice, altough the left side of the pic could've been avoided somehow. It kind of throws the rest off balance. 4

L'artiste est celui qui fait voir l'autre côté des choses
by sulis

Comment:
This is really more about abstract then Surrealism. Composition is interesting for such a challenge... 5

MORNING SMILE
by grainman9

Comment:
Pretty interesting shot. I love the lighting in it, although the clock's shadow is kind of a turnoff as it doesn't go well with the rest; kind of breaks the mood (perharps intentionaly?). Composition is nice and sure reflets the envie of Surrealism. Frame is also very important and works quite well. Nice work! 7

Invasion of the Peruvian Jolly Green Giant
by Catbird

Comment:
Now this is wierd! I went 'WHAT THE F***' when i opened this up, and that tells me you suceeded in surrealism. Unfortunatly, i really don't like the lighting, which is way too green and takes away from the model of the shot. Also the lighting is too strong and washs the whole set. Composition could've been slightly better as well but overall, pretty good. 5

Godspell
by judibrenstein

Comment:
Freaky shot. I like the idea, unforutnatly, the lighting is kind of a turnoff for me, as it doesn't offer any details or contrast of any kind. Also the background is a bit dull (behind fence). Not what i'd call surrealim, but close. 5

Queen to Rooks Pawn One (Notre Dame after hours)
by pawdrix

Comment:
Neat idea. Would've wished for a little more sharpness. I also find the moving piece idea very cool, although its not noticable a lot. Not too fond of the composition tho, as i find its a bit lost by the light emanating from the candle. 6

High energy reactor
by paha_l

Comment:
Dig the lighting in this pic. Composition is nice, although it seems the item is a bit offset and i'd wished for a more 'symetric' shot. Not too sure what to do about it and the theme tho... this ain't surrealism. 5

Stylin' Amish Man Catching Some Rays on the Beach
by Cutter

Comment:
The kind of washed colours are interesting in this shot. The composition however is not very interesting as it has many little problems (cut arm, little bit of chair on left...) which makes this pic less then super interesting. Frame is interesting. Doesnt really reflet Surrealim tho. 5

trawling for gulls
by brook454

Comment:
I have no idea what to say about this shot... Its not really interesting, out of focus, colours are weak and this has nothing to do with Surrealism. Could you have missed the wires? Tighter composition would help, as well as some good level work in PS. 3

A snapshot of 08?
by vtruan

Comment:
*cough*... i really don't understand this shot. Composition is good, but colours are rather dull; probably due to lighting... ?! 4