Don't Lean on the Railing
by trnqlty

Comment:
The snow adds a lot of interest to this shot. I would have preferred if the footprints were not quite as busy. Does not seriously detract from the beauty of this image, and perhaps that was unavoidable. :)

Other suggestions: This one appears to be straightforward B&W. To add to a more omnious mood which I think you are trying to create with your title, I think a steel blue duotone would benefit your cause.

A circular gradient fill to spotlight the the broken railing would also add a visual cue for the viewer, and subtle burning of the bottom of the steps and wooden 2x8's would also add to the drama.

(If you'd like to see my take on this shot, just PM me)

Shattered Thoughts
by KDO

Comment:
Revisiting.

This image has a moody, surreal feel to it with your given choice of lighting/hue adjustment. At first, I quickly skimmed passed this shot as another broken bulb shot. However, I can see the connection between your title and shot (lightbulb = moment of inspiring thought). Well done. This image is beyond reproach from a technical point of view, except for one small area on the screw that appears to have been burned a bit to perhaps reduce a blow out (a bit distracting loss of detail). Does not take away much from the quality of this shot, however. I am raising this one up from 4 -> 7.

Pssst...It's Buried By The First Tree On The Right
by rmtm333

Comment:
Hey Shawn! Didn't know this was yours. See, here's a picture that I like. :) I gave you a 7 on this one. Keep the great photos coming.

Windswept
by Judith Polakoff

Comment:
This is the best of the pampas grass (and variations on theme) entries. You win the Pulitzer prize for Best Grass in Inconsequential Photojournalism.

What I particuarly find fascinating about this entry is the backdrop of white trees. A nice counterpoint to the detailed and well exposed foreground subject.

Revisiting. The subtle interplay of light and shadow is quite remarkable. Bumping up.

Happiness is.....
by dtoombs

Comment:
...wonderfully captured in this warm photograph.

I like the poise and the serenity displayed by your faithful companion. Well done!

Revisiting. Sure the sky is overexposed (may have been overcast). But this is still my favorite of the bunch. 10

Windy Day Fun
by Firsty

Comment:
This has to be the most outrageous entry I've seen in a while. These kids defy gravity! Well maybe not but kudos for outstanding creativity. I'll be tuning in later to hear your story behind this quirky photograph.

Revisiting. This is just too wild. Easily one of my top three picks. 9

breeze anyone?
by Phobos

Comment:
Now this guy looks like an oddball. I think this appears too comical and staged given the lack of supporting evidence in the background bystanders. Scores well for creativity and appropriateness to challenge theme. Well done.

Revisiting. This was executed to perfection. Easily one of my top three picks. :) 9

Yellow To Gold
by spreadcom

Comment:
Wonderful creativity. This photograph was voted down unjustly for whatever reason (perhaps voters thought it was 'photoshopped').

Alternative Fuel
by redmoon

Comment:
Nice study in contrasting energy harnessing as well as a strong message in the pressing need for dependance on non-renewable sources of power. Well done.

Carry me!, and show me the world.
by Valdo

Comment:
Well done. Elegant simplicity, gracefully executed in an artistically and technically pleasing manner. Excellent backdrop to contrast with the falling feather. Your title is kinda hokey though.