Looking in
by gudbjargarson

Comment:
Sharp, focused, good DOF, and clean processing without distracting artifacts. Appears to be a rather simple profile shot but in this particular challenge, simplicity is a bonus.

Solitary Tree
by artvet

Comment:
Not a big fan of the frame but it's not distracting at all in this case.

Love the sky. This is exactly the type of picture I was hoping to see. Very well done.

Good sharpness, preservation of detail, and processing without introducing any distracting artifacts. 10

Cool and Refreshing....
by singsunshine

Comment:
Inverted and solarized? Wonderful technique to camoflauge the bottle and achieve this fluid effect. Nice, sharp image with lots of detail and processing which didn't introduce any distracting artifacts. Very abstract...I like abstract.

There's a lot of negative space, but I feel it doesn't quite come across as minimalistic (you could merely crop the right two-thirds of the frame and still have basically the same photo). I'm sure a lot of creativity and thought went into this photo and I won't deduct on this basis. Overall a solid 7.

Great Blue Heron
by coolhar

Comment:
Scored this one a 7 and I feel it's composed very well. Good sharpness, preservation of detail, and processing which did not introduce artifactual distractions. The lighting, coming from the left, leaves its face and breast a bit in the shadows, and thus its eyes are a bit shaded, yet its not that much of an issue in an otherwise fantastic entry. Well done!

Descent to Arrakis
by srbrubaker

Comment:
Nice interpretation of this challenge. I think this scored lower than it deserves, but probably because it's fairly abstract, as well as simplistic. Well done.

Rock
by gingerninja

Comment:
Just missed the ribbon, but a great placement for a great photo!

Where the Water Meets the Land
by cghubbell

Comment:
Excellent! I had a feeling this would do well, and congratulations on your first ribbon!

Cascading
by samtrundle

Comment:
Congratulations on your blue with this fabulous entry!

Ragged
by Tycho

Comment:
Congratulations on the red for a fantastic entry!

rings4.jpg
by Travis99

Comment:
Hello! Nice picture you have there. I think you nailed the DOF here. As an advertisement, I think it would work if you do something to the bottom portion or left side of the shot, which I feel would be the natural locations in this composition. Perhaps burn it some and insert a catchy phrase.

Message edited by author 2005-04-26 22:24:32.