Penguins '2006
by lsmart

Comment:
Nice B&W tones here.
Not really sure what the foreground objects are and have my eyes fighting to see what they are, taking the focal point away from the man. (6)
(curious about the title too)

Green & Gold
by BrianR

Comment:
The girl is not really singled-out by minimal dpeth of field, hurting this as far as meeting the challenge. The selective desaturation is very distracting. (3)

Good Game
by brens29

Comment:
No one here is really singled-out, especially by minimal depth of field. (3)

Have I Got a Kick Left?
by jemison

Comment:
Cool shot ! I like the way his eyes work in this shot, and not sure if this was luck or intentional, but no matter - works well for the challenge. (6)

I can fly
by dwterry

Comment:
Nobody here is really singled-out by minimal depth of field. Good action shot though. (4)

The Coach
by Nobody

Comment:
Good take on this challenge. His pose and the interest he is portraying here work well. Have you tried this in B &W or a slightly different crop? Perhaps the coach not being dead-center would work a little better? (6)

The Smallest Gymnast
by bobdaveant

Comment:
A lower angle shot here would have done this much better, though I know we can't always get in just the right place when we want. A slightly different crop here may have worked a little better, as the feet sticking in the shot on the right are distracting, though I know you wanted to get all of her feet in the shot. Play around a bit with it and see if cropping it just to the right of her shoulder works any better. (6)

Girls Club
by lyta

Comment:
Nice pose and tones here. Not really a "crowd" here though. The soft focus on the foreground girl doesn't help this a lot in my opinion and would have been a bit better had she been clear/sharp. (5)

You better move that...
by Nikolai1024

Comment:
Good street candid and a good choice for B&W. Her expression is cute.
Not sure what happened on the left side of the pic - seems like a partial border - a bit distracting, but oh well - easy fix. (6)

You Think You Know Me.
by MPRPRO

Comment:
This seems more singled-out by lighting than minimal depth of field in my opinion. The 2 people in the foreground are basically as in focus as the girl. Seems to need a slight CW rotation too. (5)