Lion Fish
by pedahel7

Comment:
I love the lion fish. This meets the challenge well. I know you could do a much better job if the little lion would hold still but I'm sure he just keeps moving. The colors are just a bit muted for my taste but being reminded this is minimal overall you did quite well catching the little bugger as well as you did. I give this one a 6.

Vexed
by riot

Comment:
Taking in consideration that this is minimal photography I think you should have done much better with this subject. It looks as if you just took a snapshot to show it was minimal but you could have done much better even if this is a candid shot. Minimal just means very little edit. This would have done better in B&W. I'm giving this a 5.

don't rush me, i'm thinking
by jmritz

Comment:
Here is another photo that I'm going to give critiquing a go. It is nicely and uniformly blurred. If this is your style you have done quite well. It truly seems to match the challenge. The only thing I can honestly say is that it looks like an office waiting room and it's not speaking to me at all and believe me I am listening but it just says "Sit down and stay awhile, then maybe you can hear me". :) 6 for you.

Night before
by lei_73

Comment:
At first glance I gave this a 5 but after looking at it again, I see what the Night before is. This must be party night before the big day, so I change my mind and that is always a girls prerogative, I give this one a 7. Colors are great and I think most of us have felt this way at one time or another even if it's simply from vertigo.

Over The Edge
by insteps

Comment:
Okay, I'm trying my hand at giving fair critiquing a go. First off my interpretation of the challenge was to take a photo with minimal edit, not minimal subject. This photo as far as I can tell meets the challenge well. Secondly I hope you're not standing on a roof to get this shot. Thirdly the color and contrast is great. It's nice to see green grass. Fourthly what is the white thing on the ground? You did a great job getting the sharp image by just holding the camera. 7 from me.

Medieval glory
by LevT

Comment:
I'm going to give it a shot and do a little critique. The building is fantablulous! I would probably want to just sit in there and take it all in. Now for the critique, the color is magnificent and as I can tell this photo meet the challenge nicely, as for the technical stuff the photo could have been rotated to make it a little more centered. This is one of those photos that does remarkably well being precisely centered. I give an 8 for this

Foxy
by jomari

Comment:
My forte' is flowers and I could not have done better. This is a beautiful shot showing you know your camera well and you know composition. This is one of my favorite photos because you did a perfect setup and composition. This is a beautiful minimal shot. I really think there is very little I would do in editing. Great Job! 10

Cheops Pyramid
by Aliaa

Comment:
This guy has captured my heart. This is a magnificent creature all dressed up and waiting for his rider. Everytime I see the photos of this guy it makes me smile. The only thing I might have done different is have Mr.C sit closer to the pile of rocks near the entrance. Mr.C I'm giving you a 10 because you have the sweetest smile.

Walking dinner
by GeorgesBogaert

Comment:
This is a great shot for minimal edit. You overall caught a celebration with great clarity. 7

réjouir
by 2mccs

Comment:
This is a wonderful shot for minimal, here again this one depicts emotion, beautifully composed and the desat is perfect. For this I give you a 10.