Evening at Sleaford
by John White

Comment:
A nice picture, and I think the triptych format does work well for it here. the composition is complex enough that the invitation to look at each part seperately is rewarding. as for the presentation, I find the drop shadow distracting. I think you'd have been better off with a more traditional outlining stroke.

Making of a Pumpkin Pie
by DeniseBernadette

Comment:
Ah, I like that you have a 'story' here. There is a much stronger concept in this piece than in a great many in this challenge. I think you could have done a bit more with your measuring spoons - look at the angles from which the three shots were taken. the measuring spoons are all straight overhead, but the pie is at a 45 degree angle. I think it would have been compositionally stronger to have the leftmost shot of the spoons also taken at 45 degrees, which would give you a nice symmetry of perspective: 45 - 90 - 45. It would also have been nice to see some more consistency in the lighting. The pie shot has a lovely soft shadow - I'd like to see that soft lighting on the spoons as well. (7)

Another day in Paradise
by Jean

Comment:
the photograph you used here is lovely, but I don't think the triptych format enhances it. the drop shadows are distracting.

Peak District Triptych
by Falc

Comment:
the three photos you have chosen are all quite gorgeous. I'm afraid I don't think your layout flatters them. both of the upper two are too close to the edges and seem to serve little compositional purpose. I could see a single photograph at the top, possibly centered between the two sides, but the two up in the corner there just don't make sense to me.

Beleaf it or not
by Beetle

Comment:
wow, that wing is the spitting image of a decaying leaf. great choice of subject for this challenge.

Lil' Hiding Monkey
by wavelength

Comment:
very cute :)

Window Dressing
by temba

Comment:
I'm afraid I don't see this as camouflage.

Decay
by metalvixen

Comment:
I'm afraid I see no link to the challenge here.

MEEOOW!!
by pearlseyes

Comment:
gorgeous contours, but I wish that the composition were a bit less abstract! I think this would have met the challenge with no less finesse if you had shown more (or the whole) of the model

"Her eyes are a deeper blue, she likes her hair that color too."
by verg

Comment:
The link to the challenge is too loose for me.