Roaring 20s
by giantmike

Comment:
Wish you'd done a little work in post on the Silvertone ring. Needs a little more detail lost in the highlights. Love the rest of it.

Old port + old cheese = delicious snack
by hajeka

Comment:
Old cheese comes in a plastic container?!

Old Weston Light Meter
by godot

Comment:
No offense intended, but it looks like an eBay photo. Could have done a lot more with a really cool prop.

a rose-red city half as old as time
by Chandi

Comment:
I love the setting, I love what you've captured from a light perspective, but I don't love the way it came together compositionally. :(

Fender Vintage Jazz Bass
by MAK

Comment:
Vintage?! Wrong pickups, wrong knobs, 3 or 4 piece body...

No points off but, I'm just curious, as a JB enthusiast, just what exactly is this?! Looks like a rather cheap 70's Japanese knock-off with a JB bottom plate.

Burrow Mump
by P-A-U-L

Comment:
Would so appreciate even a bit of perspective correction here. Unless it's really all falling in on itself in which case I apologize.

Antiques and Junque
by mlu

Comment:
Needs some perspective correction

Ohno's Pickle Caster
by vawendy

Comment:
Might have worked better with a narrower crop.

Imagine
by GeorgesBogaert

Comment:
I sort of wish you'd imagined them in something other than that shade of green.

Breakfast Diversion
by JakeKurdsjuk

Comment:

Originally posted by MadMan2k: A very interesting shape and texture study. I disagree with the need for wider DOF, I think this amount is optimal.

Thanks, Jon. Yeah, I don't agree with the need for more DoF either - there's plenty there. I have to be honest and say I'm quite disappointed with the way this scored and I suspect that it suffered at the hand of the auto-resizing on verticals as much of the detail was lost at voting size. The crop is rather tight, but that's the way it was straight out of camera. I have a personal version with more room added right and left and I suspect that the added space might have helped it somewhat, but it would have violated the editing rules. Perhaps I should have added a black frame that was wider at the sides - people wouldn't have noticed it wasn't part of the shot. LOL