Golden Hard Drive
by Brookied

Comment:
Lighting on this one isn't quite as good, imo. Still, in it's own right, I think this is well done. Good clarity, focus and tones. I just like the original one a little better because of the brightness.

Still Life: Macintosh
by gaurawa

Comment:
Terrific copy!

Portrait revisited
by vtruan

Comment:
I think this needed a better draping of the material. Other than that I like the shot a lot.

Communication - Vintage Mailboxes
by Tuckersmom

Comment:
Personally, I don't care for the crop...I would like to see a bit more mailboxes. Still, I think these are actually better than the original boxes. I like the detail on these. Nicely done.

Angel II
by arnit

Comment:
I like having the snow in the pic. I would have like the model turned a bit more sideways (as was the original). It also seems like the dodging and burning isn't done quite as artistically....not as much "character" left in the sky. A very nice attempt, though. It stands well on it's own, and it is difficult to be compared to the original!

Meet the Griswolds (Tacky Holiday Decorations)
by Prof_Fate

Comment:
Not quite as clear as the original, and the cars and people detract. Cool idea to go to the exact house though! An option most of us didn't have :)

Jumping for Victory - a change of reference
by nolock

Comment:
I'm not sure which photo inspired this one, but that doesn't affect my scoring. The ground appears overly bright and the face has a greenish/yellow tinge to it. I like the motion and the expression.

[no] Angel
by redmoon

Comment:
Cute idea, but I think technically it could be done better. I'm not crazy about the rock or whatever the doll is on. I think the dodging/burning is not done as artistically as I'd like...kinda streaky looking. The shot did bring a smile, however! :)

Second City Circa 1840
by eaglebeck

Comment:
I'm not sure this is entered in the right challenge? Feel free to pm me if I'm mistaken.

Strings Attached
by ClubJuggle

Comment:
Being a guitar player, I realy like these kind's of shots. The knob on the rear guitar is distracting IMO, however. I would have cloned it out. I would also like to see some way to lessen that shadow. Still, nice lines and colors.