Incoming
by darnok

Comment:
Greetings from the Critique Club

Isn't it nice when you get a shot that, with minimal processing, can stand up to entries that took Expert Editing to the limits!

This is a beauty, and doesn't need much of a critique from me, except to reinforce the scoring. Had I voted on this challenge my vote would have been right up there as well.

Beautiful work - wish it was mine.

Brotherhood
by michael_p

Comment:
Greetings from the Critique Club

What a delightful shot! It's always fun to see what these wide-angle lenses can do, and you took the possibilities all the way to the top.

Nicely exposed, great composition, fine expression on the kids faces, what more can I say. Well, maybe "keep up the good work!"

This was a great example of what "expert editing" can do for a photograph, while still keeping the photographic integrity of the piece.

About all I can say in closing, is enjoy those kids. They look like a whole bunch of joy.

Flowers
by mian3010

Comment:
Greetings from the Critique Club

It's always nice to see floral subjects in a triptych. They lend themselves to some unusual combinations.

Your triptych has two warm toned images and one cool one. I wonder if it would have been more harmonious to have all the flowers the same tone, either warm or cool. Then, the image on the left and in the middle have green backgrounds, while the pansy has a rather busy floral with some sort of structure in the background. You might consider replacing that with a image with a simpler background for a more pleasing effect.

Finally, yes, if your camera will support it, a shallower depth of field would work wonders to make those blossoms 'pop' because it would blur the background and take away the distractions.

I see this is only your third Challenge. Welcome to DPC, and I shall look forward to seeing more of your work.

His smile stands out from the others
by albc28

Comment:
Greetings from the Critique Club

What a happy bunch of guys you photographed. This is certainly a keeper for all your scrapbooks.

Technically, this image is a bit 'hot' and has a few distracting shadows (the left side, particularly, and the faces) that make this something of a candid shot.

Then, since this challenge was The Rule of Thirds, you will find that most people with uccessful images placed one strong subject in one of the sweet spots associated with the Rule and the rest of the composition was subordiate to that strong subject.

But all that aside, it's tough to fault a picture that shows three happy guys in fun shirts goofing off for the camera. I'm glad to have seen it and hope to see lots more images from you.

SFAlice

Two thirds of the way to summer
by joekent

Comment:
Greetings from the Critique Club

What a nice way to celebrate the coming of summer. A nice sunny day at the beach with your family.

This image has a few problems that our voters picked up on. Technically, I'd say it is a bit 'hot'. With RAW you can dial the exposure up or down, and it would be interesting to see how this would look with less light directed at the subject.

Then, since this challenge was The Rule of Thirds, you will find that most people placed one strong subject in one of the sweet spots associated with the Rule and the rest of the composition was subordiate to that strong subject. Here the flip flops are equally strong, and take away from the rule. If they were both placed in the lower right (for example) it would have exemplified the rule quite well.

Still, it is a pleasant image; one that you will have as a reminder of a happy day.

Flowing Delight
by unknowndeath

Comment:
Greetings from the Critique Club

Hello! I spent a long time looking at your interesting abstract wondering why it received such a low score. It's an abstract into which one can read many interpretations. Right now, I see a dancing figure.

Then, the light dawned: the Challenge asked us to illustrate the Rule of Thirds, and your composition has as its main attraction that nice design of white smack in the middle of the image.

Technically, I like the good definition in the bricks and the color is really good. It's a pleasing piece to look at and (imo)it surely would have received a higher score if it came closer to an interpretation of the Challenge.

I really like the way your imagination functions. Keep 'em coming!

SFAlice

Self Portrait In Bubble
by JoshuaRaineyPhotography

Comment:
Greetings from the Critique Club

Welcome to DPC. I see this is your first entry, and what a fine entry it is.

Technically difficult, you pulled it off beautifully. It's interesting on many different levels, thus keeping the viewer involved for a long time.

Just a thought - Right now, the image is almost exactly half 'n half. I wonder how this very nice image would look with just a little of the black area at the bottom cropped out.

Other than that, I'll just say congratulations on a very nice image and I wish you continued success here at DPC.

SFAlice

Burbujas de amor
by libitum

Comment:
Greetings from the Critique Club

Lovely rose, delightful capture.

And at the outset, I'll say: "they look like bubbles to me. Probably soap bubbles, at that."

While I wish people would not get 'picky' about such things as 'drops' and 'bubbles' they do and that's just a fact of DPC life. When viewers/voters look at a rose, they expect 'drops' and see accordingly. From your score, it's nice to see that many voters did appreciate the fine image you made and its bubbles.

This flower lends itself to many interpretations. Your slightly soft-focus rendition is pleasing and the bubbles turned out nice and sharp, making a good contrast. Colors are excellent, placement in the frame is appealing.

I see you are fairly new to DPC. Keep those nice images coming. I for one look forward to seeing more of your work.

SFAlice

Slide
by freakin_hilarious

Comment:
Greetings from the Critique Club

(Sigh) How does one critique an abstract... Very carefully, I know.

Seriously, I like this a lot. The composition is delightful, keeping this viewer in the picture a long time. The colors are pleasant, making the image quietly pleasing as well.

Because many of our viewers/voters have monitors calibrated differently, I've found that 'dark' images sometimes fare badly, simply because viewers can't see them properly. That's the nature of the game, and I guess it's consideration depending on what you're looking for in an entry. Personally, I'm glad you entered this one, 'cause it is lovely and a pleasure to view.

SFAlice

Early Morning Swim: Braving The Cold
by hotpasta

Comment:
Greetings from the Critique Club

You began with a very nice image, and enhanced it to a different level and you were well rewarded for your efforts. Congratulations on your very nice placement.

With a score of 6.61 and placement of 23rd out of 374, I'm not sure what I can tell you to 'improve' this image, so I'm not even going to try.

But you have an excellent track record at DPC, and if you are not already a member of the Critique Club, well, it is people of your expertise who would really help this feature of DPC.

Come on in! The Water's Fine.

SFAlice